28 Aug 2000, 18:24 UTC
SDG&E Emergency Motion for Bilateral Authority-Draft Decision
- From
- Mona L Petrochko mona.petrochko@enron.com
- To
- Douglas Condon, James M Wood, Edward Hamb, Greg Cordell, Dennis Benevides, Roger Yang, martin.wenzel@enron.com
- Date
- Mon, 28 Aug 2000 11:24:00 -0700 (PDT)
Attached is a Draft Decision approving SDG&E's Emergency Motion for authority to enter into bilateral contracts. The decision directs to enter into bilateral agreements that will expire by 12/02. It provides similar reasonableness guidance as provided to SCE (bilateral contracts must be within 5% of actual annual procurement costs). The draft decision rejects SDG&E's request to allocate those contracts to residential and small commercial customers. It rejects SDG&E's request for an exemption from the affiliate rules, which would have allowed SDG&E to enter into bilateral agreements with its trading affiliate without posting those transactions or providing an opportunity for a bid process. Because this decision adopts the same principles in the SCE and PG&E Decisions, I give a low probability to changing the decision language. However, if folks would still like us to weigh in on an issue, please let me know asap. Thanks. Mona
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
---------------------- Forwarded by Mona L Petrochko/SFO/EES on 08/28/2000 03:18 PM --------------------------- "Daniel Douglass" <douglass@ArterHadden.com> on 08/25/2000 05:26:31 PM To: <JBarthrop@electric.com>, <mnelson@electric.com>, <rschlanert@electric.com>, <Bruno_Gaillard@enron.com>, <kmagrude@enron.com>, <mpetroch@enron.com>, <susan_j_mara@enron.com>, <athomas@newenergy.com>, <Jeff.Hanson@phaser.com>, <anchau@shellus.com>, <andrew.madden@utility.com>, <ben.reyes@utility.com>, <chris.king@utility.com>, <david.bayless@utility.com> cc: Subject: Draft Decision Issued in SDG&E Emergency Motion ALJ Cooke has issued the attached draft decision with regard to the August 9, 2000, emergency motion filed by SDG&E to enter into bilateral power contracts.? SDG&E sought similar authority to that granted to Edison and PG&E in D.00-08-023.? The draft decision would grant the motion, but would impose certain conditions different from those requested by the utility.? The differences are summarized below: ? Background Under the terms of the Commission,s D.00-08-021, SDG&E is currently authorized to participate in the PX forward markets for energy services, subject to seasonal trading limits, through the end of the last utility rate freeze.? SDG&E is not proposing an increase to the limits approved in D.00-08-021 and will treat its capacity purchases under those limits, although it reserves the right to request expanded authority in the future.? The draft decision also notes that SDG&E proposes that costs associated with, and gains/losses from these bilateral contracts should be attributed only to small commercial and residential customers.? It also notes that intervenors focused on four general areas of concern regarding the specific authority requested by SDG&E: duration of contracts, reasonableness standards, request for exemption from affiliate rules, and ratemaking. ? Duration of Contracts SDG&E requested authority to enter into bilateral contracts that expire on or before December 31, 2005.? The ALJ notes that the Commission recently instituted an investigation into the impact of the functioning of the wholesale electric market on retail rates in SDG&E,s service territory and that the OII will consider whether SDG&E should be removed from that default provider role.? The ALJ states that, "the Commission should not compromise future long-term solutions by affording SDG&E greater purchasing authority than is needed to address the current emergency situation.? For this reason, we limit SDG&E,s authority to what we described in D.00-08-023 as near-term bilateral contracting authority, that is, contracts with delivery occurring on or before December 31, 2002." ? Reasonableness Standards The draft decision suggests that the OII provides a forum to establish a common framework for all three utilities for determining the reasonableness of their bilateral purchases.? However, in the interim, it adopts the same reasonableness standard for near-term contracts as it did for SCE.? "If the average price of SDG&E,s bilateral transactions, delivered or requiring delivery, over the course of an annual period exceeds the average price of SDG&E,s corresponding portfolio of transactions, delivered or requiring deliver over the same period, by more than 5%, then the Commission will initiate a reasonableness review.? Reasonableness reviews, to the extent needed, will take place as part of SDG&E,s Annual Transition Cost Proceeding." ? Affiliate Rules Exemption SDG&E's request to be exempted from the affiliate rules for any purchases from affiliates was denied. ? Ratemaking TURN urged the Commission to reject SDG&E,s request to limit the ratemaking impacts of the bilateral contracts to its residential and small commercial customers, saying that, "the potential risks and benefits should be spread among all customers."? The draft decision states that, "we do not believe it prudent to limit the cost exposure for these contracts solely to residential and small commercial customers.? This aspect of SDG&E,s motion is denied." ? Transparency Considerations The ALJ orders SDG&E to disclose all bilateral transactions to the Energy Division on a confidential basis in a monthly report.? The draft decision notes that, "WPTF and ARM argue that additional transparency of bilateral transactions is required, compared to that proposed by SDG&E.? We adopt consistent disclosure standards for SDG&E bilateral contracts as that adopted in D.00-08-023 for PG&E and SCE.? This issue may be revisited on a going forward basis in I.00-08-002." ? Response Time The normal response time has been shortened.? Parties to the proceeding may file comments on the draft decision no later than noon on September 5, 2000.? I suggest that comments be filed agreeing with the thrust of the decision, but strongly advocating that SDG&E be required to publicly post its transactions, as it agreed to do in Advice Letter 1234-E, with regard to SDG&E's participation in the Block Forward Market.? In addition, we should consider whether to refight the issue of limiting the ratemaking impacts of the bilateral contracts to SDG&E's residential and small commercial customers. ? Comments or suggestions??? ? Dan - ALJ Cooke Draft Decision.doc