18 Oct 2000, 08:48 UTC
Fwd: PowerPlus - CA Munis Propose State-Run, Non-Profit Transco For Market Woe
- From
- Ronald Carroll rcarroll@bracepatt.com
- Date
- Wed, 18 Oct 2000 01:48:00 -0700 (PDT)
Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable Date: Wed, 18 Oct 2000 08:34:02 -0500 From: "Tracey Bradley" <tbradley@bracepatt.com> To: "Ronald Carroll" <rcarroll@bracepatt.com> Subject: PowerPlus - CA Munis Propose State-Run, Non-Profit Transco For Market Woe Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=US-ASCII Content-Disposition: inline PowerPlus ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ -- In effort to regain state authority? CA Munis Propose State-Run, Non-Profit Transco For Market Woes A recent proposal by municipal utilities in California to turn the California Independent System Operator (Cal-ISO) into a state-run transmission company (transco) has piqued the interest of some industry officials who claim it will start an effective dialog on the future of the state's energy markets and the organization responsible for access to the grid, the Cal-ISO. However, the ISO argues the proposal is a non-solution and will only delay constructive discussions over the fate of restructuring in California. Others say the concept is a concerted effort by state agencies to regain control over the transmission system that California lost when the ISO was approved by federal regulators. The California Municipal Utilities Association (CMUA) proposed the concept in a statement when the organization delivered a filing to FERC seeking a return to cost-based rates in the state. CMUA filed the petition with the commission earlier this month, but FERC action on any filing regarding California's electricity markets will likely have to wait until the commission issues the results of its investigation into the state's wholesale power markets - due later this fall. While a return to cost-based rates in FERC's hands, CMUA has initiated an innovative discussion on the status of the Cal-ISO, the entity many California officials fault for some of the problems resulting from the energy crisis which plagued the state - and indeed the West - much of this past summer. CMUA claims the current ISO model and governance structure contains too much red tape which only adds unnecessary delay in crisis situations when quick action is needed. CMUA says the biggest fault with the ISO is its connection to the marketplace it oversees. Ideally, regional transmission organizations (RTOs) should not have any responsibility over markets and only needs to concentrate on managing the grid in an independent manner. By forcing the ISO to operate both the market - the ISO is responsible for managing the ancillary services markets - and the grid, it cannot be expected to run either efficiently, a CMUA source says. "The market here doesn't work," the CMUA source says. "The ISO by default has been embroiled in the market. The new transco wouldn't be involved with ancillary services." "This gets the ISO out of the market," another public power source says. "It was never envisioned to be a part of [procuring] energy supplies." Exact details of the structure of the state-run transco have yet to be resolved because any changes to the ISO will have to come from legislative and regulatory mandates, the CMUA source says. The group is considering legislation to initiate the changes, and says the concept resolves what many officials claim to be a major flaw with the ISO: its stakeholder board. Currently, the ISO is managed by a board made up of industry representatives and meets regularly each month. At the monthly board meetings, the ISO makes most of its crucial decisions on management, governance, and price caps. The CMUA source contends that the ISO does a suspect job in getting materials to board members before meetings and if the organization is state-run, it will be forced to open all executive meetings to the public. "[The transco] would be non-profit and a government agency so you have open meetings," the source says. "[The ISO] has not been good at getting material to board members before meetings." A state-run transco also would have eminent domain authority to site new transmission lines, something which the ISO currently lacks. And because the transco would both own and operate the system, it would have the necessary incentives to build more transmission, the CMUA source says. "The public agency will have the power of eminent domain," the source says. Some industry officials say the idea is part of a concerted effort among California executives and lawmakers to retain as much control as possible over the ISO. In numerous reports issued this past summer in response to the energy crisis, the ISO and its regulator FERC were seen as two of the main culprits. By making the ISO an official state agency that owns the system, California retains its authority over the grid. "This may very well play as a part of a state strategy to get more control back to California," an ISO board member says. "If it's a state agency, [the state is] going to have a much bigger role." The concept has not been well-received by the ISO, where an official there calls the idea "a solution to a non-problem." This source says the ISO has done a laudable job in maintaining the efficiency of the transmission grid and has spent nearly $800 million in transmission expansion. "This is a curious solution to a non-problem," this official says. "The market operation of the ISO is a non-issue. . . . The transmission system is being utilized much more efficiently now than it was before." The official also says that it is unclear whether a state-owned transco would meet FERC's RTO requirements and such an entity would further cloud the line between state and federal jurisdiction. "If it is a public owner, it is not clear if its federally- or state-owned," this source says. "It solves a non-problem. I don't know how easily it would be to integrate it into an interstate market."