18 Oct 2001, 21:12 UTC
RE: restrictive contract clauses
- From
- Lara Leibman lara.leibman@enron.com
- To
- Lisa Yoho
- Bcc
- Richard Shapiro
- Date
- Thu, 18 Oct 2001 14:12:38 -0700 (PDT)
sure. no problem. we've already given the doj "heads-up" on these types of provisions. however, if we'd like to provide them with specific language (crossing out any reference to certain players, if necessary), that might be a good idea. since i'm going up there (should be confirmed by tomorrow) next tuesday to see them, this is timely. lara
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
-----Original Message----- From: Yoho, Lisa Sent: Thursday, October 18, 2001 3:57 PM To: Leibman, Lara Cc: Shapiro, Richard Subject: FW: restrictive contract clauses Sound familiar? Let's sit down with Mark on this when you have time. Thanks, Lisa -----Original Message----- From: Schroeder, Mark Sent: Thursday, October 18, 2001 3:50 PM To: Yoho, Lisa Cc: Pack Jr., Scott Subject: restrictive contract clauses Lisa - as you probably know, the Pitt seam is characterised by a few dominant players, most notably Consol and RAG. Consol, especially, is resistant to our business model (transparency, liquidity). We have heard that they are putting clauses into contracts that prohibit the resale of their coal, by their utility customers. I used to know more about this area of the law, but isn't this impermissible? If so, (but don't do this, yet), is it possible to give DOJ a "heads up", so they could send appropriate demands for information? We definitely would not want our fingerprints on this. Policymakers should be on our side, as a matter of energy policy, because in times like these, when coal supplies are still tight, you want free movement of the commodity to where it is needed, when it is needed, rather than creating artificial shortages because someone long Pitt seam coal cannot re-sell it. Also, such restrictions are likely to inhibit development of effective risk management mechanisms, like the Northerern App. contract that Allegheny has been talking about (and which I understand we might put on EOL, if/when the contract is developed). Your thoughts? thanks mcs