6 Nov 2000, 10:28 UTC
Re: PennFuture's E-cubed
- From
- Jeff Dasovich jeff.dasovich@enron.com
- Date
- Mon, 6 Nov 2000 02:28:00 -0800 (PST)
Congratulations Kathleen and Peter. This ought to make this week's ARM meeting, well, sort of interesting. Viva New Power! Best, Jeff "PennFuture" <pennfuture@pennfuture.org> 11/03/2000 03:48 PM Please respond to "PennFuture" To: <Undisclosed-Recipient:@mailman.enron.com;> cc: Subject: PennFuture's E-cubed PennFuture's E-cubed is a commentary biweekly email publication concerning the current themes and trends in the energy market. November 3, 2000 Vol. 2, No. 22 Pennsylvania's First Successful CDS Auction An important new regulatory skirmish has broken out before the Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission (PUC) over which company has won the right to provide default generation service to 300,000 customers of PECO Energy, an Exelon Company. This skirmish is actually good news for consumers and is the fruit of the 1998 PECO Energy restructuring settlement agreement, a landmark document that ended a ferocious regulatory war when all combatants signed it. The &peace treaty8 includes a requirement that PECO Energy bid out default service for 20% of its customers, and PECO has done so. Green Mountain Energy Company is now challenging PECO Energy,s decision that New Power won the auction to provide the settlement,s mandated default service. Both Green Mountain and New Power are offering those 300,000 consumers small rate reductions compared to customers receiving default service from PECO, and more electricity generated from renewable energy resources. Specifically, New Power and Green Mountain are offering generation service to Rate R residential customers for approximately 5.54 cents per kilowatt-hour. That offer is 3.11 cents per kilowatt-hour less than PECO Energy,s unbundled generation and transmission rate of 8.65 cents per kilowatt-hour and 0.11 cents per kilowatt-hour less than the shopping credit of 5.65. The consumer savings that these offers represent is masked or reduced by the stranded cost payments that consumers must pay PECO Energy. Indeed, were it not for stranded cost payments, the New Power and Green Mountain offers would reduce total bills by about 3.11 cents per kilowatt-hour, or 20%. The dispute between New Power and Green Mountain is noteworthy because it proves that companies will compete vigorously to provide default service if shopping credits and lengths of contracts are set at reasonable levels. It also shows that renewable energy portfolio standards can be met economically. Finally, the result of this case will switch more customers to competitive suppliers in one day than the total number who switched in California over a period of nearly three years. When the PUC anoints New Power or Green Mountain as the winner, if all 299,300 consumers opt to stay with the CDS provider, the total number of customers in Pennsylvania that will be served by a competitive supplier will jump to more than 850,000. Of this total, 504,000 will be residential customers of PECO, a number equal to 37% of the PECO residential class. CDS Background: In Pennsylvania, there must always be a &default8 supplier or &provider of last resort8 to assure that service is always available to all customers. The incumbent utility is the default supplier, unless the PUC decides otherwise. The default supplier must provide generation service to customers who do not have a competitive supplier either because they chose not to shop or did not find a willing supplier at an acceptable price. The PECO Restructuring Case Settlement initially defined CDS service in paragraph 38: &On January 1, 2001, 20% of all of PECO,s residential customers -- determined by random selection, including low-income and inability-to-pay customers, and without regard to whether such customers are obtaining generation service from an EGS -- shall be assigned to a provider of last resort-default supplier other than PECO that will be selected on the basis of a Commission-approved energy and capacity market price bidding process. This service shall be referred to as Competitive Default Service (&CDS8).8 The same approach was used in the other Settlements in the GPU, PPL and APS restructuring cases. CDS reflects an effort to assure that there is at least one other large competitor in each market. CDS also has a renewable portfolio standard (RPS), even though there is no RPS for regulated utilities in Pennsylvania. The winning bidder must supply: &(2.0% of its offered energy supply for CDS service from renewable resources of solar, wind, sustainable biomass (including landfill gas but excluding incineration of Municipal Solid Waste), geothermal or ocean power. The renewable energy increment shall increase by annual increments of 0.5% thereafter.8 This increasing renewable requirement continues indefinitely, meaning that in year four of the CDS there will be a 3.5% renewable requirement, 4% in year five and so on. This is significant, as each extra percent of renewable energy used to serve the 299,300 customer block prevents approximately 950 tons of NOx, 3200 tons of SO2, and 390,000 tons of CO2 from being emitted by fossil fuel burning power plants. PECO,s CDS RFP: Importantly, the PECO/Unicom merger case modified the CDS bidding process as established by the 1998 settlement. Of particular note, the revisions eliminated the &customer care8 functions from CDS, made the contract three years long to help spread out return of start-up costs, and instituted several rounds of selection in the event that prior efforts yielded no successful CDS contract. PECO issued its initial RFP for CDS on April 6, 2000, and Shell Energy Services submitted the only bid. However, the PUC rejected the bid as non-conforming and denied Shell,s Petition for Reconsideration of its decision. Pursuant to the modifications in the merger settlement, PECO entered into bilateral negotiations based on an August 24, 2000 RFP. Three suppliers submitted conforming bids, and PECO selected New Power as the winner on October 18, 2000. New Power is the new competitive supplier actively marketing residential and small commercial customers in the PECO service territory and is backed by Enron, AOL, and IBM. PECO and New Power negotiated a complete contract that is before the PUC for approval on November 9, 2000. Under the proposal, PECO and New Power expanded the size of the CDS requirement to include 22% (299,300) of non-shopping residential customers instead of 20% of all residential customers, whether shopping or not. This change was designed to implement paragraph 39 of the Restructuring Settlement, requiring adjustments to the numbers assigned to CDS in order to have 35% of all PECO residential and commercial customers obtaining competitive generation as of January 1, 2001. There also will be a second round of assignment of non-shopping customers as of October 15, 2002 if New Power is providing CDS to fewer than 20% of all PECO residential customers New Power electricity will be 2% renewable in 2001, 2.5% renewable in 2002, and 3% renewable in 2003 as required, but does not include a commitment to exceed the requirements or provide cleaner power for the non-renewable portion of the product. The price for New Power,s CDS for Rate R customers would be 2.02% below the shopping credit, while residential heating customers on Rate RH would pay 1.02% less than their shopping credit. For a Rate R customer, this would mean that overall rates would fall .8% (as energy and transmission falls from 5.65 to 5.54); for Rate RH rates would fall .44%. Customers assigned to CDS may still choose any competitive supplier, or opt out and retain default service from PECO without penalty or charge. New Power will be able to offer its full slate of energy and non-energy related products to these customers. Green Mountain asserts that approval of the PECO/New Power contract is ¬ in the public interest,8 arguing that PECO ignored Green Mountain,s offer that included CDS pricing 2% below the shopping credit for all residential customers, including those on residential heating or off-peak service. Like the New Power proposal, the Green Mountain proposal would lower Rate R and RH rates .8% and .44%, respectively. Green Mountain asserts that the New Power rate cut for Rate R is only 1.83%, and not 2% and argues that its product is better for the environment because the non-renewable portion of the product would come from natural gas and hydro instead of system power generated primarily from coal and nuclear fuels. If not declared the winning bidder, Green Mountain proposes in the alternative that both they and New Power receive CDS contracts. In response, PECO states that all three bidders had the opportunity to submit revised bids and that the Green Mountain revised bid was not submitted until October 12, 2000, 13 days after the deadline and nine days after the selection of New Power as the winning bidder. The PUC will sort out the facts and arguments on November 9. Some think that the PUC may very well split the 300,000 customer block between Green Mountain and New Power. Whatever the result, customers in the Philadelphia area should receive yet another small price reduction, more renewable energy, and the opportunity for a more competitive electricity market. E-cubed is available for reprint in newspapers and other publications. Authors are available for print or broadcast. Support E-cubed by becoming a member of PennFuture * visit our secure online membership page at www.pennfuture.org by clicking on &Support Our Work.8 PennFuture, with offices in Harrisburg, Philadelphia and Pittsburgh, is a statewide public interest membership organization, which advances policies to protect and improve the state,s environment and economy. PennFuture,s activities include litigating cases before regulatory bodies and in local, state and federal courts, advocating and advancing legislative action on a state and federal level, public education and assisting citizens in public advocacy. We hope you found this informative and interesting. However, if you would prefer not to receive future issues, please reply to this email and type &unsubscribe8 in the subject line.