28 Dec 2001, 20:58 UTC
FW: ALLIANCE FERC BEAT: Generators/Power Marketers December 19 FERC Post-Meeting Memo
- From
- Vince J Kaminski j.kaminski@enron.com
- Date
- Fri, 28 Dec 2001 12:58:01 -0800 (PST)
The sender added no text of their own; everything below is quoted or forwarded.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
-----Original Message----- From: bounce-alliance_info-90961@listserver.eei.org@ENRON On Behalf Of "The Alliance of Energy Suppliers" <alliance@eei.org> Sent: Friday, December 28, 2001 12:33 PM To: Alliance Information Subject: ALLIANCE FERC BEAT: Generators/Power Marketers December 19 FERC Post-Meeting Memo [IMAGE] Generators/Power Marketers December 19 FERC Post-Meeting Memo Introduction At the last Commission meeting of the year, FERC approved the first RTO in the Midwest and issued some critical orders on RTO development, announced plans to defer action and the effects of its November market power orders, modified mitigation measures for the Western Systems Coordinating Council, reaffirmed price mitigation measures for the California ISO markets, and challenged industry to develop a "single" industry consensus organization by March 15, 2002 to be the standards-setting body for commercial business and communications protocol standards. To that end , the Alliance of Energy Suppliers and EEI encourages industry to actively participate in its national meetings being held in four regions of the country to advance the development of principles for which to form this organization. The first of the four regional meetings will be held on January 15, 2002 in Phoenix, AZ with the remaining meeting in Cincinnati, OH, New York City, and Atlanta, GA . An e-mail with all of the necessary logistical information has been circulated. If you are interested in attending or sending a company representative and did not receive the earlier e-mail, please let us know. In addition, FERC announced a series of technical conferences on standard market design and structure, market based rate /market power, and energy infrastructure. If you would like copies of any orders, please do not hesitate to contact us. Midwest ISO Receives FERC's Approval as an RTO In a series of inter-related RTO decisions, FERC approved the nations first RTO, granting the Midwest ISOs proposal to become an RTO, while rejecting a similar plan from the Alliance Companies to form the Alliance RTO. In reversing prior policy, FERC concluded that the ARTO proposal lacked sufficient scope and size to exist as a stand-alone RTO and told the Alliance Companies to explore how their business plan can be accommodated within the [MISO] structure. Allowing two RTOs in the Midwest would be a second-best solution that would compromise customers' interests, FERC stated. In related developments, FERC also approved International Transmission Company's request to transfer operational control of its transmission facilities to MISO and accepted an agreement between MISO and International Transmission that would allow the company to be an independent transmission company that would share certain RTO functions with MISO. Finally, in a related docket FERC granted in part National Grids request for a declaratory order that it is not a market participant, but dismissed the Alliance Companies business plan without prejudice as unneeded given the other Alliance order, thus nullifying Grids proposal to manage ARTO. (More detailed RTO summary provided below) FERC Delays Implementation of New Market Power Rules FERC announced that it would delay the effects of its November 20 market power orders. In FERC's December 19 order, it recognized the Alliance of Energy Suppliers' filing requesting FERC to vacate or stay the effects of its market power orders and initiate a rulemaking proceeding to allow for comments by affected industry participants, as basis for its change in policy action. We should claim this as a victory--for FERC has announced an upcoming technical conference to discuss said orders and allow industry to voice its concerns over the implications of such measures on the competitive wholesale markets. Although a date for this technical conference has not been announced, Chairman Wood said that details of the conference will be released in a notational order. FERC has also delayed implementation of certain aspects of the new Supply Margin Assessment (SMA) market power screen test. FERC Sets Schedule for Electric Market Design; Industry Told to Select Wholesale Market Standards Body or FERC Will Do So. FERC outlined a schedule for a rulemaking in the Electric Market Design docket and announced the release of a staff white paper to serve as a strawman piece for continued collaboration with interested parties on standardized electric market design. FERC stated it expected to host industry workshops in early 2002, tentatively set for January 22 -25 and February 4- 8, to further develop ideas on market standardization and issue a NOPR in March 2002. The NOPR would be followed by additional workshops in April and May to discuss NOPR inclusions and workshop developments. Written comments on the NOPR and workshop progress will also be due in May. A final rule is expected to be issued in July 2002. Although FERC staff recognized that this was a very ambitious schedule, the FERC presenter said they wanted to "get done before summer break" (2002). Meanwhile, FERC said, interested parties should evaluate NAESB, NERC and alternative proposals for an organization to develop wholesale electric industry business practice and communication standards, and agree on a single consensus, industry-wide organization to develop these standards by March 15, 2002. The Order indicated that should industry not agree on a single organization by that date, FERC would either choose an organization or institute a proceeding to develop the necessary standards. Commissioner Brownell reiterated her dismay and disbelief with industry's lag in progress: "[l]et's get this done.".. " I can't believe we're still debating the "who". The other three Commissioners indicated their general support for the Order. Commissioner Breathitt believes that this ANOPR process is working well because it "gives industry something to coalesce around." Breathitt was also in favor of industry answering the question of how much standardization do we need and how much do we need to leave to creativity and innovation? Chairman Wood concluded his remarks, saying, "[t]he GIGA-NOPR is on its way." The staff white paper covering these issues is available from the FERC website at: http://www.ferc.gov/electric/rto/mrkt-strct-comments/mrkt-strct-concept.PDF . FERC Largely Reaffirms Prior Western Market Price Mitigation Orders, Modifies Price Cap to Account for NW Winter Peaking Concerns In a broad rehearing order that addresses a wide range of issues related to California and the western energy markets, FERC generally denied rehearing requests and reaffirmed earlier decisions on pricing and price mitigation measures. The order addresses rehearing and clarification requests for the Commission's August 23, November 1, December 8 and December 15, 2000 orders along with its March 9, June 19, and July 25, 2001 refund and price mitigation orders. Among adjustments made to previous orders, FERC modified the scope of price mitigation and must-offer requirements, especially as applied to governmental sellers and cooperatives, eliminated the underscheduling penalty established in the December 15 Order, and provided an opportunity for certain entities to submit evidence that the refund methodology results in a revenue shortfall. FERC also modified and provided clarifications on setting of the mitigated market-clearing price. In particular, FERC clarified that: government sellers and cooperatives are excluded from price mitigation as its applies to bilateral transactions outside the ISO spot market and also with the must-run requirement outside of California; units operating outside of California may set the mitigated market-clearing price; the mitigated market-clearing price is to be set by the proxy price of the last unit dispatched, rather than the lower of the proxy price or the actual bid of the marginal unit; and generators subject to the must-offer requirement should be able to recover their costs for complying with the ISO's instructions to keep their units at minimum load status, and that the ISO must pay these costs, regardless of whether the ISO buys the power. Modification to Western-Wide Price Mitigation Measures In a separate order, FERC responded to industry recommendation from its October 29 technical conference and modified the price mitigation methodology for spot market transactions for the west-wide market for the winter season. FERC stated that changes would support continued price stability and balance in the western markets. The changes were called for in part, FERC said, since the area the California ISO serves is a summer peaking system and a large portion of the 11-state Western Systems Coordinating Council, consists of winter peaking systems. The changes extend from the date of the order through April 30, 2002, at which time the summer mitigation measures will be reinstated. Most notably, the new cap levels take into account fluctuation in natural gas prices. Modifications to previous mitigation measures are; raises cap level from $98 to $108 continues to apply 10 percent credit worthiness adder sets February 2002 as date that final outstanding payments be made to Western sellers of power FERC's objective through these order was to allow FERC and affected parties in the West to move forward on calculating any refunds owed and to provide greater rate certainty and stability to the market, according to the commissioners. More information on the California and western market changes is available in FERC's press release: http://www.ferc.gov/news/pressreleases/calif1-dec192001.PDF and the full order: http://www.ferc.gov/electric/bulkpower/el00-95-001-12-19-01.PDF , both available in "pdf" format from FERC's website. RTO Developments MISO Approved As Nations First RTO In approving MISOs RTO application as the nations first RTO, FERC said that it complies with the vision and requirements of Order No. 2000, in particular the requirement that an RTO be of sufficient scope. FERC cited favorably MISOs announced merger with the Southwest Power Pool and said that it was particularly encouraged by MISO's planned accommodation of flexible business plans and innovation as well as its considerable geographic span. For the most part, FERC found that MISO satisfied the four characteristics for an RTO independence, scope and configuration, operational authority, and short-term reliability, as well as key functions. FERC did, however, direct MISO to submit a number of revisions. FERC found MISO's independence satisfactory in most respects, but said that transmission owners cannot be permitted to have veto privileges on filings that affect pricing. FERC conditioned MISO's RTO status on modification of the MISO Agreement to give it the authority to propose rates, terms and conditions of transmission service under the MISO tariff. On the scope and regional configuration characteristic, FERC told MISO to present recommendations within 60 days addressing the question of its eastern seam prior to the integration of the Alliance Companies into MISO. FERC also indicated that MISO should participate in its recently announced rulemaking proceeding to standardize market design rules. However, FERC said, MISO should also address certain congestion management issues prior to implementation of standardized market rules. FERC also directed additional changes to ensure the independence of the market monitor and required modification of the planning framework to reflect that it will consider all market perspectives and to accommodate third-party investment, construction and ownership of transmission facilities. Alliance Companies Told to Work Under MISO; FERC Finds IRCA Efforts Insufficient Citing in part strong support from a majority of the Midwest state regulators for a single Midwest RTO and Alliance RTO (ARTO)s failure to achieve the necessary close coordination with MISO, FERC concluded that the ARTO lacked sufficient scope to exist as a stand-alone RTO. FERC expressed confidence, however, that the Alliance Companies' desire to be a viable, for-profit transmission business can be accommodated under the MISO Appendix I structure. FERC emphasized the importance of fostering RTO development designed to provide a seamless and robust market for millions of customers. Allowing two RTOs in the Midwest would be a second-best solution that would compromise customers' interests, concluded FERC. The Commission ordered the Alliance Companies to file a status report on their efforts to join MISO within 60 days. In the Order, FERC acknowledged the significant time and expense incurred by the Alliance Companies to date, adding that it would consider proposals for recovery of all prudently incurred costs. International Transmission Approved As ITC Under MISO In a related order, FERC said that International Transmission Company (International Transmission), a subsidiary of DTE Energy, could join the new RTO as an independent transmission company that will be able to pursue innovative business strategies. International Transmission proposes to maintain and develop transmission while turning over to the RTO such functions as congestion management and curtailments, tariff administration, and security coordination. DTE Energy has indicated its intention to sell International Transmission to a third party. FERC gave preliminarily approval for the divestiture of the transmission facilities. FERC, however, deferred ruling on several contested RTO/transco function issues until International Transmission becomes truly independent. National Grid Meets Independence Criterion, as FERC Dismisses Alliance Companies ARTO Business Plan FERC granted in part and deferred in part a National Grid proposal to manage the RTO transmission system. FERC found that National Grid is not a market participant by virtue of its retail obligations in New York and New England. FERC directed the Alliance Companies to explore how their business plan, including National Grid's proposal, could be accommodated within the MISO RTO. FERC expressed its intent to provide more guidance on this matter in future proceedings. General Discussion Signaling a deference to Midwestern state commissions, Chairman Wood said, "[w]e have brought order out of an array of various and sundry efforts in the middle of the country. . . . Its a good Christmas gift to the nation. Wood cautioned that the orders findings are based on what best serves the public interest in the Midwest, and that FERCs actions should not be construed to prejudge other types of RTOs in other parts of the country, including a structure in which a for-profit transmission company could be an umbrella RTO. For her part, Commissioner Breathitt dissented on the Alliance Order, stating that after the Alliance Companies have already spent over $75 million in start-up costs and its plans were given tentative approval by FERC over the past two and a half years, she saw no reason to abruptly change direction and deny Alliance Companies an opportunity to implement their business model. The Commission has not done all it could or should do to allow Alliance to develop, Breathitt said. Addressing the near-unanimous support among Midwest regulators for a single Midwest RTO, Commissioner Massey stated, we are heeding that advice and moving forward accordingly. For his part, the Alliance Order did not represent a change of position, he said, noting that he has long favored forcing a consolidation of the two RTO proposals. Additional details on these orders can be found in the FERC press release which is available from FERCs website at: http://www.ferc.gov/news/pressreleases/mwestxpressrel.PDF . PJM - PJM West Denied on a Procedural Basis Chairman Wood, in meeting discussion stated that the rejection was on a procedural issue only, with a delay required only because of provisions pending in other dockets. In a two-page letter order, FERC rejected the request of PJM and PJM West to integrate, but Chairman Wood assured the parties that FERC remained committed to the expansion effort and wants to see it move forward very quickly. All indications are that once the other provisions have been addressed, FERC would be ready to move forward on the PJM West effort. FERC Directs PJM To amend Tariffs to Include New Oversight Measures FERC terminated its investigation into allegations that PECO Energy Company had operated its transmission system in a manner that illegally advantaged a corporate affiliate. FERC staff indicated that the record in the proceeding did not establish a violation of the Federal Power Act or FERC's Standards of Conduct sufficient to warrant further enforcement proceedings and that further investigations into the matter were not warranted or necessary. Simultaneously, FERC accepted a report from PJM outlining a series of improvements to its current procedures for reporting of transmission outages and the rating of transmission facilities. FERC directed PJM to file amendments to its tariffs to reflect the new procedures. Commenting on the swift resolution of the matter, Chairman Wood noted the importance of lifting the cloud of an investigation promptly when the evidence warrants it. Staff Reports High Cost of Congestion; Need RTO Congestion Management, More Investment A presentation of a FERC staff report on electric transmission constraints detailed the high costs of congestion and suggested that building more transmission would likely lower overall consumer costs. The report, which FERC staff acknowledged suffered from certain data limitations, found that bottlenecks in the transmission system cost consumers more than $1 billion over the past two summers. The report also demonstrates the need for strong congestion management systems at RTOs, FERC staff said. FERC commissioners commended staff on the presentation and seemed supportive of the conclusion that building additional infrastructure would bring benefits to energy consumers. FERC staff also noted that a parallel DOE National Grid Study should be completed and released before the end of the year. The staff presentation is available in MS PowerPoint on the FERC "Discussion Papers" page at: http://www.ferc.gov/calendar/commissionmeetings/Discussion_papers.htm . Additional Commission Action FERC Issues Accounting NOPR with Question to Industry FERC issued an accounting NOPR (Docket No. RM02-3) seeking comment on whether to require unregulated energy marketers and traders to disclose holdings in derivative financial contracts used to limit risks of volatile price swings in energy purchases and sales. Chairman Wood said he looks to industry to answer the question and tell FERC that the current exemption and blanket waivers and authorizations should remain or not. Commissioner Breathitt pointed out that the current entities that must comply with reporting requirements of derivative activity are not major players in the derivative markets, but the open-ended question, if answered in the affirmative, would place burdensome requirements on a sector of the market, i.e power marketers, that most delve in that arena. Chairman Wood said that he might be in agreement with possible responses from industry that say that "maybe these processes are for another agency to do, e.g. SEC, CFTC, etc. ." Separately, the NOPR proposes changes to the Uniform System of Accounts (USA) to record transactions required under Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) Statement 115, Accounting for Certain Investments in Debt and Equity Securities, FASB Statement 130, Reporting Comprehensive Income, and Statement 133, Accounting for Derivative Instruments and Hedging Activities. The NOPR also proposes changes in the annual reports to the Commission, including the Form 1, to conform to recent actions by FASB to tighten disclosure rules. The proposal follows up Commission guidance issued in August 2001 for using the existing USA for recording transactions covered by these FASB Statements. All four commissioners endorsed the NOPR. Chairman Wood said the new rules would focus more on providing transparency to investors than broadening FERC's regulatory authority. Commissioner Breathitt commented that the new rule would seek to collect annual data, not give FERC the ability to "actively monitor" the complicated transactions. "We would be obtaining a yearly snapshot of derivative positions," Breathitt said. "I think this is a good step." FERC Staff Provides Update on Development of Standardized Interconnection Policy FERC staff reviewed the process and progress of the collaborative efforts to develop a standardized generation interconnection policy. While interconnection documents were filed on December 14th as required by the ANOPR, participants noted that the documents remain a work in progress. Participants had requested, and FERC granted on December 14, an extension of time to file the consensus documents to January 11 and to January 25 to file final comments in the docket. The collaborative process remains on schedule to take up the "money side" of the issue in April 2002. Technical Conference On Energy Infrastructure in the Northeast FERC will hold a conference in Energy Infrastructure issues in the Northeastern states on Thursday, January 31, 2002 at the Helmsley Park Lane Hotel in New York City, New York. Tonja Wicks Manager, Energy Supply Policy Alliance of Energy Suppliers Edison Electric Institute Phone: (202) 508-5098 Fax: (202) 508-5600 Fax: (202) 508-5445 ______________________________________________ To subscribe to this list, send an e-mail to alliance@eei.org containing the following information: name, company, title, address, phone, fax and e-mail address. To unsubscribe from this list, send an e-mail to alliance@eei.org containing your name and e-mail address. For more information, please contact the Alliance of Energy Suppliers at alliance@eei.org P-(202) 508-5098 F-(202) 508-5600 <Embedded Picture (Device Independent Bitmap)>