4 Nov 1999, 16:25 UTC
Re: SDG&E's Latest VBU Proposal
- From
- Harry Kingerski harry.kingerski@enron.com
- Date
- Thu, 4 Nov 1999 08:25:00 -0800 (PST)
Mona - we were just sorting through this with PGE Phase 2 and DG, with Roger, Bruno and Jeff. Questions are is it sufficient to take on issues in those cases, or is there something to gain by expanding to SDG&E? (I thought this was a pretty small market) lowering or even eliminating voltage differentials isn't by itself anti-competitive (our VBUs may have just been taking advantage of an irregularity in the previous rate design ) Do their new proposals have legitimate cost-based differentials? (I haven't seen them.) I think we should roll this up with the PGE/DG discussion, figure out our preferred policy position, and then see whether it merits any action. Thanks.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
Mona L Petrochko 11/04/99 12:38 PM To: Roger Yang, Harry Kingerski/HOU/EES@EES cc: Paul Kaufman, Susan J Mara/SFO/EES@EES, Jeff Dasovich/SFO/EES@EES, Susan J Mara/SFO/EES@EES, Bruno Gaillard/SFO/EES@EES Subject: SDG&E's Latest VBU Proposal As you know, we participated in a one-day hearing on SDG&E's attempt to slam through a rate design change that would affect the ability to do voltage buy-up deals for large customers in SDG&E's service territory. We received a favorable PD, that should be voted out today, that denied SDG&E's request but allowed them to make a more complete showing in their Rate Design Window (RDW) Filing, yet another regulatory proceeding. They have done so. There were specific, strategic reasons why we protested SDG&E's VBU proposal in the Post-Transition Proceeding: 1. Specific rate design proposals that were not relevant to ending the rate freeze were not within the scope of the post-transition filing, which is where SDG&E made its proposal. 2. SDG&E didn't provide a very thorough analysis for the cost reasons to change the rate design. The PD stated that the Commission was concerned about rate design for "prized customers". 3. We were concerned about the precedential affect such a rate design proposal would have relative to the other utilities. 4. At that time, we were still interested in offering facilities-based services, like VBUs. Distribution competition and interconnection issues associated with building substations are within the scope of the OII on Distributed generation and distribution competition proceeding, which seems to be the appropriate forum for addressing the overall issue of the utilities' ability to thwart facilities competition through anti-bypass rate design. Despite the fact that the overall policy will be determined in the DG proceeding, it seems that the Commission is perfectly willing to address specific proposals in the utility-specific proceedings (ie. PG&E GRC 2, SDG&E's RDW). Now that it appears as though our business interest on facility-based competition has waned, is there any interest in addressing the VBU issue in SDG&E's RDW Proceeding?