Enron email

Algorithmic Indexing

25 May 2001, 02:57 UTC

RE: ERCOT Board Meeting

From
Thane Twiggs thane.twiggs@enron.com
To
James D Steffes, Richard Shapiro
Cc
Jean Ryall
Bcc
Jean Ryall
Date
Thu, 24 May 2001 19:57:00 -0700 (PDT)
First of all, we did not have any advanced notice of the appeal to the ERCOT 
Board.  Mark Walker from ERCOT called me regarding their application and told 
me that it would probably be denied and at that point nobody, I doubt, knew 
that TNPC would appeal.    The rules appear to be cut and dry.  Basically, 
for them to have a full corporate membership Enron would have to own less 
than 5% to avoid the common ownership criteria for EPMI.

I spoke to Marianne after the Board Meeting.  She felt uncomfortable when I 
told her the I was upset because I did not know about the appeal and that the 
way that the appeal was handled at the board.  Short answer is that Marianne 
did not feel at liberty to tell us about the appeal for whatever reason.

It appears that we will be the only representation that TNPC will have for 
their REP.  I will bridge the gap with Susan Burton in the Austin office to 
try and help them with their issues.  One problem is that in her attempts to 
&show8 that they are not controlled by ENRON, I sense a reluctance on her 
part to be forth coming with their issues.  I have spoken to others at TNPC 
that are willing to discuss issues and how we can support them.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
-----Original Message-----
From:  Steffes, James  
Sent: Thursday, May 24, 2001 7:08 AM
To: Shapiro, Richard
Cc: Twiggs, Thane; Ryall, Jean
Subject: Re: ERCOT Board Meeting

First, I agree that there is a basic conflict when our attorney represents 
TNPC.  If Marianne was instructed not to inform Jean, etal than there is a 
real problem.  If it was an oversight, we should simply make sure that 
Marianne understands the importance of keeping all of her clients happy.

I don't have any problem with TNPC wanting to have a seat at ERCOT.  They are 
supporting many of the same issues, and may take a stronger stand then us.

Finally, if we are the only rep at ERCOT for TNPC, I think that we need to 
make sure that we understand their issues and can "fit" them in to our agenda.

Jim





Richard Shapiro@ENRON
05/23/2001 07:50 PM
To: Thane Twiggs/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT
cc: Jean Ryall/NA/Enron@Enron@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, James D 
Steffes/NA/Enron@Enron@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT 

Subject: Re: ERCOT Board Meeting   << OLE Object: StdOleLink >> 

I am greatly disturbed by Marianne Carroll's role in this episode...Were we 
given advance warning? Should we revisit her continued representation of both 
us and New Power? Jim- Is this latter issue one we should revisit nationally?



Thane Twiggs@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT
05/16/2001 01:36 PM
To: Stacey Bolton/NA/Enron@Enron, Leslie Lawner/NA/Enron@Enron, Ron 
McNamara/NA/Enron@Enron, Gloria Ogenyi/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, 
Lance Cunningham/NA/Enron@Enron, Thane 
Twiggs/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Nancy Hetrick/NA/Enron@Enron, 
clandry@enron.com, pochsner@enron.com, bevin.hunter@enron.com, Jean 
Ryall/NA/Enron@Enron, Joe Allen/NA/Enron@Enron, Patrick Keene/NA/Enron@Enron, 
Doug Gilbert-Smith/Corp/Enron@ENRON, Christopher Ahn/Enron@EnronXGate, James 
D Steffes/NA/Enron@Enron, Christi L Nicolay/HOU/ECT@ECT, Mike 
Curry/Enron@EnronXGate, Drew Tingleaf/Enron@EnronXGate, Larry 
Jester/Corp/Enron@ENRON
cc: Richard Shapiro/NA/Enron@Enron, dietrich janet 

Subject: ERCOT Board Meeting

The ERCOT Board met yesterday in Austin to discuss among other things the 
implementation of the Texas Choice Pilot and the single control area under 
the control of the ERCOT ISO.  Below are the primary items of interest.

1.   ERCOT proposed the following plan to implement the Pilot program and the 
wholesale:

May 25, 2001

ERCOT begins to transfer security analysis to the ESCA system
Participants able to start viewing network conditions, preliminary load 
forecasts, preliminary A/S market requirement analysis, and retail load 
profiles
ERCOT begins to manage and publish participant information and process 
customer service requests

June 1, 2001

ERCOT initiates switch processing from competitive retailers starting with 
small volumes and to be completed by July 1, 2001 (this is only the switch 
request, power does not "flow" from the REP until the billing cycle after 
July 6, 2001).
ERCOT begins to process retail meter read information.
Participants begin to enter outages in ERCOT systems (this will be parallel 
to current outage system entry).
ERCOT will begin to publish distribution and transmission loss factors to the 
market.

June 8, 2001

ERCOT Begins to complete data aggregation functions and initiates UFE 
calculations/analysis.
ERCOT's A/S market requirements and QSE obligation Calculations are ready for 
sing control area operations
ERCOT begins to execute the production settlement algorithms.  The settlement 
results are not binding.
ERCOT begins to transfer grid security decisions to the new systems
Data aggregation allows initial calculations of UFE to be made visible to the 
market providing energy accounting information

July 6, 2001

Frequency Control.  ERCOT begins single control area operation and 
controlling frequency.  The existing control area replaced with the single 
control area run by ERCOT.
Wholesale Markets.  ERCOT administers the regulation, balancing energy, and 
reserve markets.  ERCOT starts clearing prices as part of single control area 
operations.  The wholesale competitive market, as defined by the protocols is 
initiated with ERCOT settling A/S markets centrally.
ERCOT begins to execute financial transfer processes as a result of binding 
settlement with participants
QSEs must have completed qualification activities


While the proposal satisfies many of the competing concerns of the 
Stakeholders and the PUCT, there are a few outstanding issues that remain.

ERCOT will begin switching load transfer requests on June 1 2001, but actual 
settlement and energy flow will not occur until after the wholesale market 
opens on July 6, 2001.  Enron has submitted a proposal that would allow the 
retail market to decouple from the wholesale market which would allow the 
wholesale market time to remedy the system limitations and the retail market 
could begin June 1, 2001.  Under the ERCOT timeline if the wholesale market 
is not ready by July 6, 2001 and the switch requests have already begun, then 
there is no method to serve a customer full requirements without the ability 
of the REP to purchase balancing energy and other A/S other than purchasing 
under current tariff.  I can provide a copy of the Enron proposal to those 
who are interested.

Another concern is for reliability of the system.  Some parties question the 
wisdom of opening the wholesale market in the middle of the summer peak, 
rather than waiting until the summer peak has passed.

  
2. Credit Standards.  The Board also voted on language for the surety bonds.  
There has been a debate as to whether ERCOT should allow security bonds in 
light of what has happened in California and the surety bond that was 
underwritten by AIG.  At this point, the PUCT order requires ERCOT to accept 
a surety bond, however, ERCOT is trying to tighten the payment language.  The 
language that the board approved will be forwarded when I get the correct 
language.  The board approved the addition of BBB- credit to the credit limit 
matrix.


3. New Power Company made an unsuccessful appeal for corporate membership.  
New Power argued that they were technically not an affiliate of EPMI who 
holds the Corporate Membership.  EES for example has associate member 
status.    It was pointed out by ERCOT that EPMI listed New Power as a 
corporate affiliate on their application for corporate membership.  Marianne 
Carroll, represented New Power in the appeal, and stated that EPMI did not 
ask her advice prior to listing New Power as affiliate.  An additional 
rationale cited by New Power was that in the future Reliant Energy wants to 
"spin off" their generation company and that when they do, they should be 
allowed a Corporate membership as well.  I am concerned about the appearance 
of the appeal by New Power, it looked like an attempt by Enron to sway the 
process in "their" favor by getting additional votes on ERCOT issues.


Thane Thomas Twiggs
Enron Corp
1400 Smith Street
Houston, Texas 77002

713-853-3199 Voice
713-408-4463 Mobile
713-646-8272 Fax
877-968-8967 Digital Pager or 8779688967@skytel.com