17 Nov 2000, 17:15 UTC
Argentina and Emerging Markets
- From
- Jeffrey A Shankman jeffrey.shankman@enron.com
- Date
- Fri, 17 Nov 2000 09:15:00 -0800 (PST)
FYI.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
---------------------- Forwarded by Jeffrey A Shankman/HOU/ECT on 11/17/2000
05:16 PM ---------------------------
Robert Johnston
11/17/2000 09:15 AM
To: Gary Hickerson/HOU/ECT@ECT, Max Yzaguirre/NA/Enron@ENRON, Jeffrey A
Shankman/HOU/ECT@ECT
cc: William Stuart/HOU/ECT@ECT, Shane Dallmann/LON/ECT@ECT, Pushkar
Shahi/HOU/ECT@ECT, Ellen Su/Corp/Enron@Enron, Michelle D
Cisneros/HOU/ECT@ECT, Trena McFarland/NA/Enron@Enron, Eric Scott/HOU/ECT@ECT,
Paul Pizzolato/HOU/ECT@ECT, Aaron Armstrong/LON/ECT@ECT, Jurgen
Hess/LON/ECT@ECT, Martina Angelova/LON/ECT@ECT, John Greene/LON/ECT@ECT,
Scott Tholan/Corp/Enron@Enron
Subject: Argentina and Emerging Markets
The crisis in Argentina has a lot of people talking about another emerging
market crisis. This source believes that such talk is overblown, at least
for now.
RJ
ARGENTINA:THE UNPALATABLE CHOICE AMONG DEFLATING, DEFAULTING OR DEVALUING
Executive Summary
The recession in Argentina is deepening and the government faces painful
choices in addressing it
While the current strategy of deflation is unpopular, default or devaluation
could be even more painful
Deflation will remain the strategy of choice so long as De la Rua survives;
if his government falls, both default
and devaluation become likely
Mexico and Brazil are in a stronger position to face the fallout from a
devaluation than they were in 1998
November 16, 2000
1. Argentina Recession
The question haunting observers of Argentina is whether the De la R?a
administration will succeed
in stabilizing the country,s economy and pulling it out of its second
recession in five years. Indeed,
the 11-month old administration has not lived up to expectations and is
quickly losing market
confidence. Although the country has so far maintained the support of the IMF
and Washington,
the outcome of the unfolding crisis is by no means certain. Argentina is
trapped in a fixed
exchange regime that succeeded in taming inflation but is now impairing its
competitiveness and
long-term prospects.
2. Deflate, Default, or Devalue?
The administration faces a number of unenviable choices as it tries to reduce
the difference
between internal and external prices. It can continue with its present course
of action, attempting
to cut its fiscal deficit amid a deepening recession and a growing debt
crisis. The adjustment of
relative prices would thus be accomplished through continued deflation. A
variant of this scenario
would be to renegotiate part of its external debt, in order to reduce the
increasingly onerous interest
payments, or default on its sovereign bonds. This, however, would destroy the
last shred of
confidence, jeopardize Argentina,s future access to international capital
markets, and ruin the
country,s relations with major industrialized countries. Finally, the country
could opt to devalue.
Arguably, the financial and social cost of this action would be high, but the
country could recover
relatively quickly, as the cases of Mexico and Brazil suggest.
3. Recession Threatens De la Rua Survival
The outcome will depend on whether the De la R?a administration remains in
power. The
government is committed to pursuing a deflationary adjustment, hoping that it
will pay off by next
year, provided that the US dollar weakens and that its access to
international markets is
maintained. However, if the deflation is more prolonged and the economic
recession becomes
socially and politically untenable, the ruling coalition could disintegrate
and the president could be
forced to resign. In that case, the new government would probably decide to
devalue immediately
after taking power.
4. Brazil and Mexico Less Vulnerable to Contagion than in 1998
The Argentine crisis has raised the specter of emerging market financial
instability, notably in
Brazil and Mexico. However, these fears may be unfounded given the progress
made by the latter
countries in improving their fundamentals. Indeed, both Brazil and Mexico now
feature a floating
exchange rate regime and have gone a long way in terms of balancing their
fiscal accounts. Thus,
in the event of an escalation of Argentina,s difficulties, both countries are
well equipped to
overcome temporary financial turmoil.