1 Dec 2000, 13:28 UTC
Dynegy comments on PX proposed Code of Conduct
- From
- Joe.Paul@dynegy.com joe.paul@dynegy.com
- To
- barbara_klemstine@apsc.com, dcazalet@apx.com, billr@calpine.com, jackp@calpine.com, ken_czarnecki@calpx.com, Carolyn A Baker, gavaughn@duke-energy.com, rjhickok@duke-energy.com, kewh@dynegy.com, jdasovic@enron.com, susan_j_mara@enron.com, curt.hatton@gen.pge.com
- Date
- Fri, 1 Dec 2000 05:28:00 -0800 (PST)
fyi
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
---------------------- Forwarded by Joe Paul/HOU/Dynegy on 12/01/2000 11:25 AM --------------------------- Joe Paul 12/01/2000 11:48 AM To: "Pat Gillman" <PGILLMAN@schiffhardin.com> cc: <Gene_L_Waas@calpx.com>, kamarlantes@calpx.com Subject: Dynegy comments on PX proposed Code of Conduct Dear Pat, Attached are the comments of Dynegy regarding the proposed PX Code of Conduct. You have received or will shortly receive comments from PG&E and SCE that Dynegy supports. To the extent that some of the suggested changes can be adapted to the current rules, (as suggested by PG&E) we would be willing to assist you in making those changes consistent with our comments. We continue to believe, as our comments have pointed out, that many of the suggested changes are vague, overly broad, have no standards of materiality, fail to distinguish between types of offenses in the punishment and severity, prohibit the legitimate assertion of procedural and substantive rights, levies excessive fines, provides for no de novo review and provide no comfort at all that any information submitted on a confidential basis will be afforded the proper protection. I know that considerable effort has gone into the development of these rules, but it is our position that the proposal you are making goes way beyond any authority that the PX thinks may have been delegated to it by FERC. As has been pointed out, the PX is not a self regulating body, but one that is regulated by FERC. With respect to our comments, I have used the redline method to highlight changes and comments to the PX 11-03 draft. On your tool bar there are 3 icons that you can use to navigate through these comments. As part of my comments regarding the confidentiality tariff (Section 19.3.3), I have referenced a non-disclosure agreement. This is in an attached file called "protective order". Unfortunately, I could not make any changes (since it is in a PDF format) but as you read through it, you can see that it is easily adaptable to a non-disclosure agreement and covers all the points that I referred to at the last meeting. Finally, please understand that my failure to comment on any section does not indicate approval. The areas I pointed out, in addition to those covered in the PG&E memo, are the major points of departure. (See attached file: Dynegy Comments 2nd draft code of conduct.DOC)(See attached file: protective order.pdf) - Dynegy Comments 2nd draft code of conduct.DOC - protective order.pdf