16 Jan 2001, 18:04 UTC
RE: Smith Enron Cogeneration Plant - shareholder complaint/Attorney Client Privilege
- From
- Otto Gonzalez otto.gonzalez@enron.com
- Cc
- katrin.haux@enron.com, Mariella Mahan, John Ambler, david.shields@enron.com, eggie.pichardo@enron.com
- Bcc
- katrin.haux@enron.com, Mariella Mahan, John Ambler, david.shields@enron.com, eggie.pichardo@enron.com
- Date
- Tue, 16 Jan 2001 10:04:00 -0800 (PST)
Letter is fine with me. Thanks, Otto
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
Michelle Blaine 01/16/2001 01:00 PM To: Otto Gonzalez/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT cc: Katrin Haux/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Mariella Mahan/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, John Ambler/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, David Shields/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Eggie Pichardo/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Richard B Sanders@ECT Subject: RE: Smith Enron Cogeneration Plant - shareholder complaint/Attorney Client Privilege I have confirmed that Mr. Badger and his wife are both named plaintiffs in the Costambar litigation against SECLP. Because they are involved in pending litigation against us, we really cannot give them anything but a "non-answer" answer attached. If there are no objections I'll send this to Mr. Badger. thanks! Michelle Otto Gonzalez 01/11/2001 09:01 AM To: Katrin Haux/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT cc: Mariella Mahan/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, John Ambler/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, David Shields/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Michelle Blaine/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Eggie Pichardo/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT Subject: RE: Smith Enron Cogeneration Plant - shareholder complaint Katrin, This is indeed a sensitive matter and must be treated accordingly. I do strongly suggest that before anything you talk to Michelle Blaine of our litigation team who is very up to date on the class action cases the Costamabar comunity has against SECLP. There are many half truths and many lies involved. The plant team has for long been aware of the responsability and are very diligent and careful to comply with the environmental standards applicable. One problem here is that across the bay from where we are, there are two other power plants (one of them which I managed) and also produce "noise" and air emissions, one within applicable World Bank standards but no the other, which belongs to a third group. The prevailing winds bring the emissions from those plants directly to our plant and the Costambar community. Our air emissions (within WB standards - monitored during the year) mostly go down wind southeast away from Costambar. So there are many variables involved. We must be careful with the shareholder letter since it is very likely the person may be part of the class action and is fishing for something. But Michelle can advice you appropriately. If you need any further data from the plant after talking to Michelle please let me know. Many thanks, Otto From: Katrin Haux 01/10/2001 07:41 PM To: Otto Gonzalez/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT cc: Mariella Mahan/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, John Ambler/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT Subject: RE: Smith Enron Cogeneration Plant - shareholder complaint Otto, The following shareholder complaint about Smith Enron's plant in Puerto Plata was sent to Investor Relations and today forwarded to our attention, requesting assistance with this matter. The gentlemen sending the complaint owns a home in Costambar, a residential community, which, according to his e-mail, has been negatively affected by our plant. He mentions a disturbing noise level, decreased air quality, dwindling property value and power outages worse than prior to the plant going online. The fact that we take any shareholder complaint very serious, I am preparing a response to this letter and I am asking for your help. Could you provide me with any background information on the alleged complaints and confirm or deny the issues at matter? Are there any plans on the way to address any possible issues? It had been my impression that the Smith Enron plant not only had no negative effects on the environment but that great efforts were made to improve the local community through community relations programs like the public park adoption, supply of school materials, shipment of medical supplies and the municipal nursery support. Can you expand on this? I realize that this matter has to be managed with extreme caution. I clearly will coordinate my reply with you and seek additional approval from legal prior to responding to the gentlemen. Thank you in advance for your support and cooperation. Best regards. -- Katrin -----Original Message----- From: Gordon Badger [mailto:badger@estation.com] Sent: Friday, December 15, 2000 10:08 AM To: investor-relations@enron.com Cc: public-relations@enron.com Subject: Smith Enron Cogeneration Plant - Puerto Plata, Dominican Republic ? Iam an Enron shareholder through my holding company First Foundation Financial Services Inc. Five or six years ago Smith Enron floated in and installed a power generation plant at Puerto Plata in the Dominican Republic generating power to sell to the Dominican power agency. Presentations were made at the time to the local (mostly American and Canadian) residents in the community of Costambar, where the plant was to be (and was) built, that: ???????? The noise would not exceed &the sound of the ocean8, ???????? That there would be no air quality damage, and ???????? That the power outs in Costambar would cease. I have a home in Costambar about a half mile away and over a large hill from the plant. ???????? The sound is audible in the entire neighborhood; ???????? When they clear the boilers it is oppressive/ear shattering for the entire community of 800 homes ) in spite of the retrofit silencers; ???????? There is often molecular ash falling and on occasion ) well documented with pictures ) total black soot coverage down wind for a quarter mile or more; ???????? Costambar is on the country,s grid and has power outs for an average of two or more hours per day ) worse than before. In other words, all of the well-documented and witnessed undertakings have been proven false. I was proud of Enron at the beginning because there seemed to be a legitimate attempt to do the right thing. As time has progressed, however, it has become clear that there is no solution to the continuing problems. It is also obvious that the ONLY right thing is to pull up stakes and float the plant to the original alternate location down the coast ) or to another country. The problems are insoluble. You simply can,t plop a large energy burning facility beside an upscale community without event. For a company as knowledgeable as Enron should be concerning the effects to nearby residents, it borders on inexcusable that the plant would have been built where it is in the first place. Having attempted any number of solutions and now recognizing the absence of solution, the continuing inexcusable action is to &carry on regardless8 as ahs been the case for the past two or more years. Enron has been sued by the adjacent (large) hotel which, although only two or three years old when the plant was built, had to shut down because of unending guest complaints and refund demands. It now sits as a rotting monument to the problems. Unfortunately for Enron, the owners are a prominent Dominican family. I am told they already have a large judgement - but are going for more. If they haven,t already they surely will ) and they surely should. What was once an attractive and productive facility is useless and will remain fallow as long as the plant is there. Soon it will fall totally beyond repair and there will be no alternative but to raze it. Houses in the immediate area ) say ? mile/100 homes ) have fallen 50% to 75% in value, and houses in the community at large have fallen 10% to 50% in value dependent upon their proximity to the plant. Whereas the hotel value is in the low millions and the ultimate award will likely be commensurate, the loss in value to the homes is in the tens of millions. Beyond these financial events, some of the people in the community are beginning to complain about new respiratory and other pollution related ailments. The rough estimate of damages ranges between US$100 million and $150 million without considering the health issues. The community has sensible and responsible leadership and has responded in a sensible and responsible way.? Dissatisfied with the failure to solve the problem in any approaching a timely fashion, the homeowners have recently retained competent counsel. Nearly 400 homeowners have joined the class action to recover their lost property value. The issue of determining lost value is about to formally begin and the total loss calculated. Soon there will be no turning back because of the homeowners, investment in the action. If there were an announcement that the plant is to be moved the claim from the community would almost certainly go away with the possible exception of damages for? the few homes that have changed hands during the plant,s life here. If the plant remains, the action will proceed ) and all things being equitable, which they ultimately become in the Dominican court system, there will be large claims awarded. I imagine they will massively overshadow the few million dollars to move or dismantle the plant. ? ? I now take off my homeowner,s hat and return to my position as shareholder. The following (italicized) statements form part of the Enron Mission Statement. As noted above the company has so far failed to implement these visions as noted. ? environment In everything we do, we operate safely and with concern for the environment. The way we do a job will affect how our children and our neighbors' children will live in the future. This is a responsibility we take seriously in all the different places around the world where we do business. The Costambar environment has been seriously effected from a noise and air pollution point of view. ? integrity We work with customers and prospects openly, honestly, and sincerely. When we say we will do something, we will do it; when we say we cannot or will not do something, then we won't do it. The community was seriously misled and Enron has been unable to develop solutions to restore or correct their documented assertions. ? creativity We think the entrepreneurial approach stimulates creativity. It calls for new insights, new ways of looking at problems and opportunities, and a strong sense of urgency. The problems have persisted for several years with no recent new initiatives directed at solving them. ? respect We treat others as we would like to be treated ourselves. We do not tolerate abusive or disrespectful treatment. Ruthlessness, callousness, and arrogance don't belong here. The Golden Rule has long since gone wanting in this situation. ? It is simply not responsible for Enron to continue with a facility that has and continues to damage a community, financially and from a health point of view. And it is not financially responsible of Enron management to risk the payment of tens of millions in claims arising from damages that can otherwise be avoided at quantifiable and much lower cost. I,m sure the company has a thick file on this issue already. I,m equally sure, however, that the measure of damages is reaching a new phase and is approaching the point where there will be no will by the litigants to turn back. The plant was constructed during the waning days of the environmentally insensitive Beleaguer government. The country has undergone substantial changes since then including changes in The Rule of Law and the judiciary. There is now a new liberal government that is likely to be very generous with one of its previously model communities if the matter reaches the courts. The loss to the shareholders of Enron from inactivity of management is likely to be immense ) and is avoidable. I would appreciate a comment on management,s views as quickly as possible. ? ? Sincerely, D. Gordon Badger ? ? badger@estation.com Puerto Plata tel - 809 970 7184; fax - 970 7134 ? ? ? ?