31 Oct 2000, 12:52 UTC
FW: Commissioner Lynch Comments at the CCPUC Meeting on Monday
- From
- Brian Cherry bkc7@pge.com
- Date
- Tue, 31 Oct 2000 04:52:00 -0800 (PST)
Thought you might enjoy this. Don't pass it on....
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
> -----Original Message----- > From: Cherry, Brian > Sent: Thursday, October 26, 2000 7:25 PM > To: Williams, Ray; Johnson, Kirk; Thomas, Dan (CGT Dir); Katz, > Michael; Campbell, Benjamin; Bellenger, Geoffrey; Berkovitz, Trista; Gee, > Dennis; Buchner, Les; Lindh, Frank (Law); Litteneker, Randall (Law); > Niven, Andrew (Law) > Cc: Guliasi, Les; Hapner, Dede > Subject: Commissioner Lynch Comments at the CCPUC Meeting on > Monday > > At Monday's CCPUC conference, Commissioner Lynch outlined objectives > and priorities as President of the Commission. I thought you might be > interested in her remarks, especially as they relate to our Gas Accord II > settlement efforts. > > Commissioner Lynch identified several general objectives she would > pursue as Commission President: > > 1) Decision-making under her leadership will be arrived at based > upon well developed facts and arguments - not theories. > 2) The Commission will rely on legal principles for guidance, not > ideology. > 3) Future decisions must recognize the diversity of society > interests, not just those of the applicants and interveners. The > Commission will take proactive steps to generate community support, > especially among those groups who have been "overlooked" in the past. > 4) The Commission must understand and account for their decisions in > the real world. Therefore, decisions will not be voted out until the > Commission has evaluated their impact in the broader sense: on the > community, on the state, on the general welfare. > 5) The Commission's priorities (described below) need to be better > articulated and communicated to all of California's citizens. > > With those objectives stated, Commissioner Lynch went on to describe > her personal priorities at the Commission. > > 1) The public interest is the paramount and guiding principle of > her administration. Commissioner Lynch emphasized that decisions must > benefit all Californians and stated that recent decisions haven't > reflected this. She noted that many groups are under-represented (such as > environmentalists) and stated that decision-makers bear a responsibility > to inject the public interest into the decisions of those not represented > before the Commission. Taking a swipe at the Republican majority, she > noted that recent Commission's have been enamored with competition. To > her, "...competition is merely a tool, not an end unto itself. Had the > impact of electric competition been better understood, decisions would > have been made differently." > > 2) Certain practices at the Commission must change, especially > those involving a utilities' right to withdraw an Advice Letter after > submittal. Without mentioning names (although many concluded she was > aiming at Sempra's withdrawal of a number of AL's over the last few > months), Commissioner Lynch stated that utilities should not be allowed to > withdraw an AL to avoid a draft resolution they don't like. She stated > that draft resolutions must be voted out and not be subject to veto by the > utilities. She stated that the Commission was looking at changing the > General Order allowing utilities their right to withdraw AL's. > > 3) Settlement rules do not allow the Commission to make sure that > the public interest is considered sufficiently. According to Commissioner > Lynch, under the current settlement rules non-settling parties have the > burden of proving that a settlement is not in the public interest. She > wants to change the settlement rules to reverse that concept - applicants > must bear the burden of proving settlements truly are in the public > interest. Specifically, she does not like the fact that the settlement > rules bar the public or non-settling parties from settlement conferences. > As such, she believes settlements halt the development of an evidentiary > record and present facts to the Commission that cannot be tested. Going > further, Commissioner Lynch stated that she was not interested in > maintaining the "peace" and would reverse settlements contrary to the > "public interest" (without defining the public interest). She also stated > that her staff was currently working on revisions to the settlement rules. > > > 4) The Commission will be less reactive and more proactive. That > is, the Commission cannot rely upon parties to articulate pressing issues > nor can the Commission rely on parties to resolve issues on a piecemeal > basis. Commissioner Lynch's recommended solution is that there needs to > be more consolidated dockets and decisions to prevent, ".. disjointed, > choppy decisions" from being made. In an effort to make the Commission be > more proactive, Commissioner Lynch stated that we will see more OII and > OIR's coming out of her administration. > > 5) The Commission will follow the law as written - period. > Commissioner Lynch stated that there was no need for the Commission to > "interpret" the law. Her discussion here focused on mergers and > acquisitions. She stated that 24 (?) out of the last 24 > merger/acquisition decisions voted by the Commission approved the > merger/acquisition request. She believes that this proves the Commission > is relying upon expediency at the expense of the law with regards to > transfers of control. (My notes are fuzzy here, so perhaps someone else > who attended can better articulate her position). > > 6) Decisions must be based upon facts - not theories or > convictions. Electric restructuring was again held out as the prime > example of a Commission decision focused on "..convictions, based upon > ideological theories, not fact-based thinking". Commissioner Lynch stated > that she wanted to hear reasoned arguments, not excuses or vague claims of > financial distress. She stated that she will take real claims of > financial distress seriously, but they must be backed up by concrete > evidence, not rhetoric and anecdotes (although $2.9 Billion seems pretty > concrete to me....editors note....). She also stated that she would not > tolerate an absence of a sufficient evidentiary record nor would she allow > lobbying to "interfere with the process". Robust records and clearly > articulated briefs must be the norm if parties want the Commission to act > upon their claims. > > 6) Consumer protection is PARAMOUNT. Commissioner Lynch stated > that she supports the Telco "Bill of Rights" and would like to see it > applied across industries. She once again stated that competition can > never assure that customers will get what they really need. Therefore, > the Commission needs to extend its hand to local community-based > organizations for input into the decision-making process. She also stated > that consumer abuse, in any form, should be prosecuted to the fullest > extent of the law by the Commission and the Courts. > > It's a lot to think about, especially as we move forward in our Gas > Accord II settlement discussions. > > > > >