18 Jan 2000, 18:09 UTC
Re: Credit Trading OnLine - Results of Legal Due Diligence and Risk Memo
- From
- Mark Dilworth mark.dilworth@enron.com
- Cc
- Paul Simons, Bryan Seyfried, John Sherriff, Jeffrey T Hodge, Julia Murray, Mark Taylor, Michael R Brown, Edmund Cooper, Justin Boyd, rod.sayers@enron.com, Janine Juggins, Steve W Young
- Bcc
- Paul Simons, Bryan Seyfried, John Sherriff, Jeffrey T Hodge, Julia Murray, Mark Taylor, Michael R Brown, Edmund Cooper, Justin Boyd, rod.sayers@enron.com, Janine Juggins, Steve W Young
- Date
- Tue, 18 Jan 2000 10:09:00 -0800 (PST)
Louise I've spoken with Bryan - your understanding is correct - there will initially be circa 250 products total spread across the product types (which are defined by the country of incorporation of the reference credit). He is hoping to grow this quickly. M Louise Kitchen 18/01/2000 16:57 To: Louise Kitchen/LON/ECT@ECT cc: Paul Simons/LON/ECT@ECT, Bryan Seyfried/LON/ECT@ECT, John Sherriff/LON/ECT@ECT, Jeffrey T Hodge/HOU/ECT@ECT, Julia Murray/HOU/ECT@ECT, Mark Taylor/HOU/ECT@ECT, Michael R Brown/LON/ECT@ECT, Edmund Cooper/LON/ECT@ECT, Justin Boyd/LON/ECT@ECT, Rod Sayers/LON/ECT@ECT, Janine Juggins/LON/ECT@ECT, Steve W Young/LON/ECT@ECT, David Weekes/LON/ECT@ECT, David Forster/LON/ECT@ECT, Elena Kapralova/LON/ECT@ECT, Mark Dilworth/LON/ECT@ECT Subject: Re: Credit Trading OnLine - Results of Legal Due Diligence and Risk Memo Bryan Mark told me that in the meeting (legal trading weekly conference call, Paul spoke of a different 250 products per country? Is this right? This has some serious implications. Could you let us know as this hasn't come up before I had assumed your 250 products were the same whatever the country. Regards Louise
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
Louise Kitchen 01/17/2000 07:07 PM To: Paul Simons/LON/ECT@ECT, Bryan Seyfried/LON/ECT@ECT cc: John Sherriff/LON/ECT@ECT, Bryan Seyfried/LON/ECT@ECT, Jeffrey T Hodge/HOU/ECT@ECT, Julia Murray/HOU/ECT@ECT, Mark Taylor/HOU/ECT@ECT, Michael R Brown/LON/ECT@ECT, Edmund Cooper/LON/ECT@ECT, Justin Boyd/LON/ECT@ECT, Rod Sayers/LON/ECT@ECT, Janine Juggins/LON/ECT@ECT, Steve W Young/LON/ECT@ECT, David Weekes/LON/ECT@ECT, David Forster/LON/ECT@ECT, Elena Kapralova/LON/ECT@ECT, Mark Dilworth/LON/ECT@ECT Subject: Re: Credit Trading OnLine - Results of Legal Due Diligence and Risk Memo Thanks very much for your memo Paul it is very helpful. I attach below for completeness the To Do list put together by Elena in order to put Credit on EnronOnline. There are two remaining issues which require further thought:- 1. How do we want to display Credit on a long term basis on EnronOnline. For the short term, we can put credit out there but the number of updates will be restricted. Using Jay's best guess on a slow network connection the initialization process will take upto 4 minutes and on a normal connection 250 updates every 30 seconds would prevent people from trading. So we do have some scaling issues? Our model doesn't really function for simultaneouse changing of hundreds of products so really we need to actually get a much better specific on how many updates you envisage. Do you really envisage that many updates? Also we haven't yet experienced fast updates which we will do when FX joins the system. 2. We have approximately 4000 guest id and passwords? Can these see credit pricing from a due diligence perspective. Elena will be leaving the EnronOnline group at the end of this week and Mark Dilworth will be our main point of contact in Dave's absence. Any questions please do not hesitate to call me (713 853 3488). Louise Outstanding Credit Derivatives Issues Action Status Resolved by 1. Redraft Credit Derivatives GTCs Decide how many GTCs are needed ) 1, 2 or 6 ) and prepare the draft(s) accordingly with following issues in consideration: ? Change &Effective Date8 language to refer to the dates on the website. ? Cofidentiality issue ) legal advice is to leave it out. Bryan Seyfried to make decision on commercial basis, whether not to include it at all, or include the softer clause, for ex. that counterparties cannot use Enron name when disclosing transactions, details. ? Include &bad faith8 provision to prevent sleeving. ? Decide what entities should enter transactions on Enron side ) ECTRI for Europe and ENA for North America (?) ? Get Tax sign-off Paul Simons/Edmund Cooper/Slaughter&May 2. Translation of GTCs Decide whether translations are needed and, if so, prepare them: ? Nordic GTC into Norwegian ? Swiss GTC into German Paul Simons/Edmund Cooper/Slaughter&May 3. Withholding Tax Issue Do further research and take a view regarding US Withholding Tax issue, i.e. that US entity can only transact with another US entity. Jannine Juggins/ Paul Simons Legal Validation of Long Descriptions Make sure that Long Descriptions are aligned with GTCs. Edmund Cooper 4. Legal Review of Paper Confirmations Modify language in the paper confirmations according to GTCs and Long Descriptions. Edmund Cooper 5. Translation of Paper Confirmations If necessary, prepare the following translations: ? Nordic Conf. - into Norwegian ? Swiss Conf - into German Paul Simons/Edmund Cooper 6. Draft Consent Paragraph to be included in the Marketing Letter ? Draft a consent paragraph to be added to the Marketing Letter that goes to Ref. Entities companies ? Get PR approval Paul Simons/Edmund Cooper 7. Confidentiality Lists Identify counterparties in the Confidentiality Lists (all Enron entities) that will be used as underlying Reference Entities and get their written consent. Paul Simons/Edmund Cooper/Mark Taylor 8. Confidentiality Procedures Prepare Procedures and educate Enron traders that confidential information about Ref. Entities is not misused. Paul Simons 9. Prepare Counterparty List Prepare the Counterparty List and forward it to Legal (for capacity check) and Credit for approval. Note: List must contain exact entity name that will be entering Cr. Deriv. transactions Bryan Seyfried 11. Capacity Check on Counterparties Check counterparties, constitutional documents to make sure that they have legal power and authority to trade Cr. Deriv. Note: Finish counterparties must be &professional investors8. Paul Simons/Edmund Cooper/Mark Taylor 12. Get Counterparties List Approvals Bryan to chase Credit/Legal/Traders to get there sign-off. Bryan Seyfried 13. Complete Reference Entities List ? Add information on country of incorporation and abbreviation (up to 12 characters) to the existing Ref. Entities List. ? Get Traders, Legal, Credit and Tax (?) approval. Bryan Seyfried/Raj Sharma 14. Attach Cr. Deriv. GTCs to all Cr. Deriv. transactions confirmations Make sure that Back Office procedures are amended accordingly. Bryan Seyfried/Barry Pierce 15. Investigate whether companies from Canada and Germany can be used as Ref. Entities For time-being Canadian and German companies won,t be used neither as Ref. Entities nor they will be able to enter trades as counterparties. However, being Ref. Entities ) needs further investigation. Paul Simons/Edmund Cooper/Mark Taylor 16. Legal Budget Estimate approx. legal fees budget for Cr. Deriv. Paul Simons 17. Short Descriptions Change Short Descriptions: ? Product Type should read: &US Credit Dflt8, i.e. not &US Cr Dflt Swap8 ? Upload Underlying Credits (Ref. Entities) abbreviation according to Raj,s List. Elena Kapralova/Mark Dilworth 18. Online Test Set up Cr. Derivatives in the Test environment and make test trades. Bryan Seyfried and Cr. Deriv. traders 19. Set up New Database If decision on placing Cr. Derivatives as a separate page is final, start working on coding a separate Cr. Derivatives Database. Mark Dilworth to co-ordinate with IT 20. Sigma Factors Set-up Sigma factors on the Product Type level. Mark Dilworth to co-ordinate with Credit 21. Risk Calculation Set-up methodology for risk calculation on underlying Ref. Entities. Mark Dilworth to co-ordinate with RAC Legal Deliverables ) Credit Derivatives Deliverable Jurisdiction Delivery Date Status Delivered by 1. GTCs All Slaughter&May 2. Long Product Descriptions Validation All Edmund Cooper 3. Translation of Norwegian and Swiss GTCs into German and Norwegian if necessary Norway, Switzerland Slaughter&May 4. Paper Confirmations All Edmund Cooper 5. Translation of Norwegian and Swiss confirmations into German and Norwegian if necessary Norway, Switzerland Slaughter&May 6. Consent Paragraph in the Marketing Letter All Paul Simons/ Edmund Cooper 7. Confidentiality Procedures N/A Paul Simons 8. Further info on Canadian and German companies as Ref. Entities Canada, Germany Paul Simons/ Edmund Cooper Credit Derivatives ) Resolved Issues Resolved Credit Derivatives Issues Action Status Resolved by 1. 2. 3. Paul Simons 01/17/2000 02:01 PM To: John Sherriff/LON/ECT@ECT, Louise Kitchen/LON/ECT@ECT cc: Bryan Seyfried/LON/ECT@ECT, Jeffrey T Hodge/HOU/ECT@ECT, Julia Murray/HOU/ECT@ECT, Mark Taylor/HOU/ECT@ECT, Michael R Brown/LON/ECT@ECT, Jeffrey T Hodge/HOU/ECT@ECT, Edmund Cooper/LON/ECT@ECT, Justin Boyd/LON/ECT@ECT, Rod Sayers/LON/ECT@ECT, Janine Juggins/LON/ECT@ECT, Mark Frevert/LON/ECT@ECT, Rick Buy/HOU/ECT@ECT, Steve W Young/LON/ECT@ECT, Shirley A Hudler/HOU/ECT@ECT, David Weekes/LON/ECT@ECT, David Forster/LON/ECT@ECT, Elena Kapralova/LON/ECT@ECT Subject: Credit Trading OnLine - Results of Legal Due Diligence and Risk Memo NOTE - GIVEN THE PROPOSED LAUNCH DATE OF 24 JANUARY 2000 FOR THIS PRODUCT, THIS NOTE IS INTENDED TO SERVE BOTH AS A SUMMARY OF THE RESULTS OF OUR LEGAL DUE DILIGENCE AND AS A RISK MEMO As you know, we have carried out legal due diligence in the eight countries where it was intended the credit product would initially be traded via EnronOnLine - namely, the UK, the US, Canada, Finland, Germany, Norway, Sweden and Switzerland. Under the terms of the credit product, on the occurrence of a bankruptcy with respect to a specified third party (the Reference Entity) the Seller of the product (which could be either Enron or its online counterparty) will pay a fixed, pre-agreed cash sum in an agreed currency to the Buyer. (It should be borne in mind that this product differs in a number of ways from the more conventional credit derivatives traded in the international markets. This means that a change in the nature or terms of our product or the introduction of alternative credit products will likely change the analysis below.) Set out below is an overview of where we have come out on the more significant legal issues. I am also attaching a two page "Executive Summary of Legal Advice" prepared by outside counsel which highlights the significant legal issues/risks in each country and which should be read in conjunction with this note mail. As you will see, the Executive Summary does not focus on issues we raised which are "all clear" from a legal perspective, so as to keep the summary to a sensible length (but there was plenty of good news too!). Where a legal issue has been identified, I have either set out below what action is to be taken, or not addressed it further on the basis that, on the advice of foreign counsel, the risk is not very substantial or unlikely to materialise. Therefore, where no comment is made below in relation to a risk highlighted in the attached summary, please assume that the legal risk is one which, in our view, it is reasonable to take. A. Countries in which the credit product can be traded in January 2000 Finland, Norway, Sweden, Switzerland, UK, US B. Countries in which launch of the product via EnronOnline will need to be delayed Canada, Germany (reasons set out below) C. General Issues (applicable in all countries) The credit product is fundamentally different from the usual energy and related products we trade and so gives rise to new or increased legal risks of a general nature: (i) Capacity - We will not be able to assume generally that our counterparties will have the legal power and authority necessary to trade the product and so will need to check each counterparty's constitutional documents before allowing them to trade the product online. This applies to almost all entities (eg corporates, municipalities, insurance companies) in all countries. Some entities may lack the power to trade under the general law (in which case we will not be able to deal with them at all) or under their constitutional documents (in which case they will need to amend their constitutional documents if they wish to trade). The check need only be made once at the beginning of the credit trading relationship and so can be added to our procedures. It is not a particularly onerous job and will increase the cost of this business only incrementally. (ii) Confidentiality - We will need to put in place procedures to ensure that we are not misusing confidential information about our business counterparties on whom we are offering credit protection. Misuse can occur both in pricing the product and trading it. The procedures will not include formal Chinese Walls separating the credit traders from our other traders or the credit department (a point we have managed to agree with both UK and US counsel following very detailed discussions). The procedures will include (a) the use of a Restricted List in both the US and Europe (similar to the procedure currently used in Houston); and (b) practical steps to ensure that confidential information derived from other areas of our business and which we are not entitled to use (eg because it is the subject of a confidentiality agreement) is not imparted to the credit traders. In addition, where Enron has an especially close relationship with a prospective reference entity, or otherwise has confidential information relating to such an entity, we will need its written consent before offering protection on that entity. Without such consent, there will be an unjustifiably high risk of being sued by that entity for breach of confidence. D. Country Specific Issues (i) Canada - There is a substantial risk that the product will constitute insurance business, constituting an offence and rendering contracts in the product unenforceable against our counterparties. We should try to resolve this issue with the Canadian authorities before launching the product in Canada. Timeframe for clearance is highly uncertain since it is not clear which Canadian authority would take jurisdiction of the matter. (ii) Germany - Again the issue is insurance. The risk is higher than in Canada and so Germany should be excluded initially. (iii) Norway - There is a material risk that the credit product could be regarded as gaming in Norway, in which case trades would be void and unenforceable. The normal way to mitigate this risk in Norway is by using a "substantial professional effort" to satisfy ourselves that a trade is being entered into for valid commercial purposes (normally hedging) by our counterparty. Clearly, it will not be possible to take such steps on a trade by trade basis in the context of EnronOnline. At a minimum, we should therefore ensure at the outset of the online trading relationship in this product with each Norwegian counterparty that there is a commercial logic behind its trading this product type. (iv) Switzerland - If the credit product is the main purpose of our trading relationship with a counterparty, we should check with the Swiss supervisory authority whether the product constitutes insurance (the position being unclear). If a trade is insurance, it can be terminated by the counterparty (which is obviously of greater concern if Enron is the Buyer) and an offence will be committed since Enron is not authorised as a Swiss insurer. However, I understand that the initial group of counterparties will be existing business relationships, in which case we can parallel path this issue. (v) US (New York Law) (a) CFTC regulation - by structuring the product either as a swap or an option (and meeting certain other conditions) we can rely on exemptions under the US Commodities Exchange Act. (b) US securities laws - there is a small chance that the credit product constitutes a "security" under US securities laws (please see attached Executive Summary). However, SEC regulations allow the public offering of securities to "accredited investors" which will allow us to deal with investors having at least US$5 million in assets. Since most of our counterparties will be fairly large, sophisticated players, this test should not impede the business. (c) Insider trading - US counsel have advised that the risk of insider trading occurring as a result of the product being characterised as security (see (b) above) is relatively remote. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ -------------------- Please feel free to call me on x36566 if you would like to discuss this project further. Best regards Paul