12 Mar 2001, 16:58 UTC
TGS Update/strictly privileged and confidential
- From
- Michelle Blaine michelle.blaine@enron.com
- To
- Robert C Williams, Rob Walls Jr., Bruce Lundstrom, Peter E Weidler, Mark E Haedicke, Richard B Sanders, John Novak, miguel.mendoza@enron.com
- Date
- Mon, 12 Mar 2001 08:58:00 -0800 (PST)
The Province of Rio Negro in Argentina claims TGS owes approximately $352 million in stamp taxes, interest & penalties.; TGS recently filed its final administrative appeal in Rio Negro against that province's stamp tax assessment.;;The administrative process normally could take a couple of more months, but because the Province of Rio Negro could reject;the appeal any day and seek to collect the taxes, TGS has no choice but to immediately seek an injunction in the Argentine Supreme Court.; Once Rio Negro rejects the appeal (which it will), TGS waives its right to go to the Supreme Court for an injunction, a risk it cannot afford to take.; ; This suit could potentially have a negative impact on Enron's bilateral investment treaty (BIT) claim in the International Center for the Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID), because the parties are required to make an election under the BIT.; In other words, a party cannot have previously filed suit for relief in the local court if it seeks redress in ICSID arbitration.; Technically, Enron hasn't filed in the local court, and;we will argue that Enron's claim under the BIT is independent of; the TGS claim in local court.; This;argument is novel, however, and it is not clear how it will play out.;;Recall that on February 22, 2001, Enron filed its ICSID claim for a declaratory judgment against the Republic of Argentina for the actions of both Neuquen ($224 million assessment);& Rio Negro provinces.; Therefore, even if ICSID rejects Enron's;claim;regarding Rio Negro, the Neuquen claim should remain valid giving Enron leverage for negotiation with the federal government.;; ; ;In late 1999, TGS filed an action in the Argentine Supreme Court for a declaratory judgment and;injunction against the Province of Santa Cruz ($17million assessment).; Our local contacts inform us that despite precedent to the contrary, the Supreme Court appears to be leaning toward granting at least a partial injunction in that case. ; About a; month ago, the federal government and the provinces tentatively agreed to do away with the stamp tax prospectively and the federal government would provide another income stream for the provinces.; As you are aware, President de la Rua recently asked his entire cabinet to step down following the resignation of Economy Minister, Machinea, citing the troubled economy, now in its 32nd month of recession.;;Machinea's office;has been fairly ineffective as the arm of the federal government addressing the existing stamp tax issues among the provinces, producers and transporters.; Therefore, de la Rua's appointment of an orthodox, hard line economy minister, Ricardo Lopez Murphy, is seen by investors as positive.; It is unclear how this governmental change will impact the tentative agreement on the future of stamp taxes, but I am investigating.; We will make arrangements to meet with Mr. Lopez Murphy, as we have with the past government officials concerning the stamp tax, its impact on Enron, and on the foreign investment climate in Argentina. Please call me if you have any questions.; x56159. Regards, Michelle