1 Sep 2001, 02:16 UTC
Selling BPA Surplus Energy
- From
- Steve C. Hall c..hall@enron.com
- Date
- Fri, 31 Aug 2001 19:16:37 -0700 (PDT)
Here are some refinements to our protocol for selling BPA Surplus Energy. I have consulted with Marcus Wood on this, and he agrees with my analysis on these points:
1. We can sell BPA Surplus energy to public bodies and cooperatives ("munis") outside of the Pacific Northwest. Therefore, the rule that "Surplus needs to touch a NW muni" should be expanded/relaxed to be "Surplus needs to touch a muni." Stated in another way, the only customers we cannot sell Surplus power to are IOUs and marketers.
2. Purchases of BPA Surplus that we sell only within NW are not subject to 60-day recall. Likewise for Surplus energy we use to replace non-hydro resources that we then export. Therefore, the 60-day recall provision only applies to energy that is exported out of the region, or that replaces hydro resources that are exported outside of the region.
Steve
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
-----Original Message----- From: Wood, Marcus [mailto:MWOOD@stoel.com] Sent: Friday, August 31, 2001 3:50 PM To: Hall, Steve C. (Legal) Subject: RE: BPA Questions Let me give you the basic answers, but I should follow up next week with a discussion of details that are crucial in implementation: 1. Sacramento PUD and other out of region public bodies and cooperatives indeed are entitled to be treated as public preference customers. 2. However, in a sale to an out-of-state utility, regional preference trumps. In other words, even if the customer is a public preference customer, the sale of power to the customer is subject to 60-day recall. 3. Sales of power within the region are not subject to the 60-day recall. 4. As a general matter, I think you can use federal power to displace a non-hydro resource in the Northwest and then sell the output of that displaced resource out of region. However, (1) if the resource owner is a "private person or agency," there will be a defect in the initial resale of Surplus Energy to such resource owner. In addition, under Section 9(c) of the Northwest Power Act, a preference customer seeking long-term requirements service from BPA cannot must treat such displaced resource as serving its loads, so that BPA is required only to provide service to the reduced load after such imputed service. These matters might best be addressed in the context of specific desired transactions. -----Original Message----- From: Hall, Steve C. [mailto:Steve.C.Hall@ENRON.com] Sent: Friday, August 31, 2001 3:15 PM To: Wood, Marcus Cc: Walters, Stephen; Yoder, Christian Subject: BPA Questions Marcus, After taking a fresh look at the Bonneville-related statutes, I have some new insights that I would like to test. Please read over these conclusions and let me know if you agree, disagree, etc. This can definitely wait until next week. 1. Under section 5(a) of the Bonneville Project Act, no "private person or agency" may resell BPA power to any "private utility or agency engaged in the sale of electric energy to the general public." We have always interpreted this to mean that we must sell BPA Surplus Energy to NW munis. After reviewing this provision today for the first time in months, I now believe that we are not limited in selling to NW munis, but instead can sell to "public bodies and cooperatives" both inside and outside the Northwest. My thinking is that the Project Act does not tell us who we can sell to, but only who we cannot sell to, e.g., a "private utility or agency engaged in the sale of electric energy to the general public." Accordingly, there being no restrictions on selling to non-NW public bodies and cooperatives, we can sell to them. I believe that we can sell BPA surplus power, consistent with federal law, to any public body or coorperative. Do you agree? 2. Who is eligible to be a preference customer? Why can't Sacramento MUD become a preference customer? Under Section 4(d) of the Project Act, the only requirements seem to be that the customer be (1) a public body or cooperative that is (2) "within economic transmission distance of the Bonneville project." Although the Northwest Power Act incorporates the Project Act, I do not see that it limits this eligibility to publics in the the Columbia river drainage basin. Can any public body or cooperative that is "within economic transmission distance of the Bonneville project," i.e., California, New Mexico, Arizona, become a BPA preference customer? 3. Sales of BPA Surplus energy that are (1) sold within the region, or that are (2) used to replace non-hydro resources, which are exported out of the region, are not subject to the 60-day recall provision under the Preference Act. Do you agree? Steve ********************************************************************** This e-mail is the property of Enron Corp. and/or its relevant affiliate and may contain confidential and privileged material for the sole use of the intended recipient (s). Any review, use, distribution or disclosure by others is strictly prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient (or authorized to receive for the recipient), please contact the sender or reply to Enron Corp. at enron.messaging.administration@enron.com and delete all copies of the message. This e-mail (and any attachments hereto) are not intended to be an offer (or an acceptance) and do not create or evidence a binding and enforceable contract between Enron Corp. (or any of its affiliates) and the intended recipient or any other party, and may not be relied on by anyone as the basis of a contract by estoppel or otherwise. Thank you. **********************************************************************