17 Oct 2000, 16:15 UTC
S m o k e a n d S m e a r s
- From
- Christopher DeMuth cdemuth@aei.org
- To
- harvey.golub@aexp.com, neill@alcoa.com, jricketts@ameritrade.com, amworks@aol.com, blountwm@aol.com, hertogrz@bernstein.com, bk@caxton.com, hcrow@crowholdings.com, john_snow@csx.com, wsstav@dow.com, henwendt111@earthlink.net, klay@enron.com
- Date
- Tue, 17 Oct 2000 09:15:00 -0700 (PDT)
S m o k e a n d S m e a r s Christopher DeMuth and Steven Hayward October 17, 2000 In the closing weeks of the presidential campaign, Vice President Gore is returning to the theme that Governor Bushs Texas has become an abysmal place to live. It is a hard case to makeTexas is today the fifth fastest growing state and fifth in net influx of Americans from other states, and Mr. Bush is one of the nations most popular governors. Mr. Gores earlier attacks on the governors education record were set aside following the July release of a comprehensive RAND study showing that Texas has become the nations top state in achievement test scores. His subsequent assertions about the number of Texans lacking health insurance seem to have fizzled as well (it turns out that the number of uninsured has been falling in Texas while rising in the nation as a whole). That leaves environmental quality, where the Vice President and his ad writers have leveled a fusillade of dramatic allegations about increasing pollution in Texass cities and streams. Environmental quality presents rich opportunities for misleading data and rhetoric. Measuring air and water pollution involves a host of variables: one can measure pollution by emissions or by the quality of the air and water, and measurements of air and water quality depend on the placement of monitors, the use of *peak* versus average levels, and adjustments for population exposure and for the widely differing health and amenity effects of different kinds of pollution. Rankings among states are much more problematic than rankings of school performance or health care, because all states that are more urbanized and industrialized have higher pollution levels. Texas accounts for 60 percent of the nations petrochemical production capacity and 25 percent of oil refining, and it is the only state with two metropolitan areas (Houston and Dallas-Ft. Worth) among the nations top ten. Measured by simple gross quantities, Texas, California, and New Jersey will have *more pollution* than most other states under any circumstances; the rest of us can enjoy the products without having to bother so much with the pollution-control challenges. Mr. Gores charges exploit these opportunities to the hilt, combining misleading statistics with a few outright fabrications to create an impression that bears little relationship to reality. The charges are, however, easy to debunk, and it is surprising that they been reported with little scrutiny by a media that has otherwise grown wary of the Vice Presidents loose ways with facts. The Gore campaigns favorite charge is that Houston has passed Los Angeles to become *the smog capital of the United States,* *No. 1 in air pollution,* and *the dirtiest city in the nation.* (We will ignore Democratic National Committee Chairman Joe Andrews claim that Houston has become *the dirtiest city in the world,* which was evidently uttered in a fit of enthusiasm for the latest party line.) The charge is false. According to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, air quality in Houston is improving and is unambiguously better than in Los Angeles, and is also better than in many other cities. The Houston charge is based on 1999 city data on ambient levels of ozoneone of six *criteria* air pollutants regulated under the national Clean Air Act as measured by numbers of days of *exceedences*of the EPAs national standard. Ozone levels are highly sensitive to weather conditions, especially temperature. They have been essentially flat in Houston in recent years (and other southern cities such as Atlanta), but they fell sharply in Los Angeles in 1999 due to unusually cool summer weather. As a result, Houston topped Los Angeles (and all other cities) in ozone exceedencesbut its air quality was nevertheless better than LAs. Houstons ozone level was 10 percent higher than in Los Angeles, but its particulates level was 20 percent lower (particulates are the other major component of *smog,* and according to the EPA a far more serious health risk than ozone; there is no separate measure of *smog*). Houston did vastly better than LA for three of the four other Clean Air Act pollutants: 63% lower for nitrogen oxides, 64% lower for carbon monoxide, and 78% lower for lead (the cities sulphur dioxide levels were identical). While Houston was out of compliance with EPAs national standard for only one pollutant, ozone, LA was out of compliance for three: ozone, particulates, and carbon monoxide. We hasten to add that we are comparing Houston with Los Angeles only to demonstrate the falsity of Mr. Gores allegation. If Houston is not number one in air pollution, neither is it number two or even number six (Houston is the nations sixth largest metropolitan area). According to the EPA Air Quality Index, which aggregates levels of all six air pollutants and weights them according to the health risks of each, air quality in Houston is better than in ten other metropolitan areas. Houston also bests ten other cities on a separate EPA index of ozone alone. (These data are for 1998, the most recent year available; rankings for 1999 and 2000 will probably be similar.) A related charge, and particularly egregious falsehood, is Vice President Gores assertion that Governor Bush *made key air pollution rules in Texas voluntary.* In 1999, Governor Bush signed two laws concerned with *grandfathered* sources of air pollution. Under the Clean Air Act and almost all state air pollution programs, old power plants and industrial facilities are subject to much more lenient emissions standards than new ones. It is a serious loophole that has been bad for the economy as well as the environment inducing firms to maintain old facilities (both less efficient and more polluting than new ones) for longer then they otherwise would, and leading to protracted litigation over the difference between renovating an old facility and building a new one. Under the 1999 legislation, Texas became one of the first three states to begin closing the loophole through tighter standards for old facilities. The step was praised by environmental groups and helped coax Mr. Gore, who had not previously confronted the problem as a legislator or Vice President, to propose a national program of his own for old power plants. (Mr. Bush has also advanced a national proposal.) But there was a wrinkle in the Texas initiative: the law covering utilities enacted mandatory standards (which will result in huge reductions in power plant emissions over the next three years), but the law covering industrial facilities enacted a *voluntary* compliance schedule coupled with increased fees for noncompliance. There is legitimate disagreement over just how effective the fee-incentive program will turn out to be; there have been some initial reductions in the first year, apparently of about 25,000 tons of air pollution, but the program is too recent to estimate likely future reductions. What is not in dispute is that both the *mandatory* and *voluntary* prongs of the Texas program constitute an extension and tightening of air pollution controlsand an innovation that powerful business opposition has thwarted at the national level and in most states. Nor is it disputed that the use of economic incentives rather than regulatory mandates may significantly improve the effectiveness of our environmental laws and are worth a try; indeed, that is precisely the approach of the Vice Presidents national proposal for old utilities, which consists not of mandatory standards but *voluntary* tax incentives. For Mr. Gorea self-described environmentalist and reformernow to turn on the Texas reforms and describe them as having weakened existing pollution standards (*Bush made key air pollution rules voluntary*) is an act of striking mendacity. His latest campaign ad adds a particularly ruthless twist: it couples the *made voluntary* fabrication with the Houston air quality fabrication to produce a triple falsehoodthat air pollution got worse in Houston because Governor Bush weakened air pollution standards. The Vice Presidents most plenary change is that, under Governor Bush, Texas has become *last among all states in air quality,* *No. 1 in industrial air pollution,* and *No. 3 in water pollution.* Although the Gore campaign has occasionally relied on newspaper articles and rankings produced by environmental groups, its primary and only official source for these claims is an EPA compilation called the Toxics Release Inventory. The TRI, however, is not a useful measure of air or water pollution and is not a measure of environmental quality at all. Instead, it measures *releases* of certain substances that the EPA classifies as toxicand *releases* includes not only those that pollute the air and water but also those that are properly disposed of through EPA-approved hazardous waste management and water treatment practices. The agencys annual TRI reports warn that its estimates *reflect releases and other waste management activities of chemicals, not exposures of the public to those chemicals,* and that they are not sufficient to determine exposure or harm to the environment or public health. So the TRI numbers cannot possibly support Mr. Gores assertions. But even in their own terms, they tell a story that is the opposite of what the Vice President would like voters to believe. Texas has always been near the top of the various TRI ratings, reflecting the states huge share of national petrochemical and refining capacity. But it did not become No. 1 in the overall ranking under Governor Bush, as the Gore campaign insinuates. Rather, Texas was No. 1 under Mr. Bushs predecessor, Democratic Governor Ann Richards, and it has improved significantly since he took office. The EPAs 1999 release of TRI data through 1997 noted that *Texas, the state with the largest production-related waste managed in 1997, was also the state projecting the largest absolute reduction . . . over the next two years.* The data for 1998, released earlier this year, shows Texas leading the nation in reduction of toxic releaseswith 43 million pounds eliminated between 1995 (the first year of Mr. Bushs governorship) and 1998. The new report also finds Texas leading all other states in energy recovery and waste treatment, and second in on-site recycling. Due in part to these improvements, Texas has now dropped from first to fifth place in the TRI composite index. Environmental quality in Texas has improved under Governor Bush according to virtually every useful measure. Here are a few selected statistics of our own: According to the Texas Natural Resources Conservation Commission, industrial air emissions in Texas fell 11% from 1994 through 1998. According to the EPA, ambient air quality in Texas improved for five of the six national air pollutants for the same period, all Texas cities but one now meet the national standards for four or more of the six pollutants (the exception, El Paso, due to cross-border pollution from Mexico), and half of Texass cities are now below the national average for all six pollutants. According to the EPA, Texass proportion of rivers and streams classified as *impaired* is better than the national average. And according to Environmental Defense, which prepares a comprehensive index of water quality aggregating 15 Clean Water Act pollution measures, Texas is not *No. 3 in water pollution* but No. 37its overall water quality is better than in 36 other states. Governor Bush does not get all of the credit for this record; it is also due to the progressive tightening of national environmental standards and, perhaps even more, to progressive improvements in production technologies. But he gets a share of it, due to his own decisions and those of his appointees. And in several critical areas of environmental policy, he has been a national leaderclosing the old plants loophole, redeveloping *brownfields* laid waste by the perverse incentives of the Superfund program, providing positive incentives to businesses for *pollution prevention* and to private landowners for conservation and species protection, and improving the financing of public parks and recreation areas. *Texas-style environmental regulation,* which the Gore campaign invites us to fear, is, like Texas-style school reform, something Americans can look forward to. _____________________ Mr. DeMuth is president of the American Enterprise Institute in Washington, D.C. and Mr. Hayward is a senior fellow at the Pacific Research Institute in San Francisco. Both are policy advisers to Texas Governor George W. Bush. - Enviro.wpd