9 Apr 2001, 15:28 UTC
Capacity Auction Agreement Working Group for ERCOT (CAAWG - ERCOT) and SPP (CAAWG - SPP)
- From
- Thane Twiggs thane.twiggs@enron.com
- To
- Bruce Sukaly, Mike Curry, jducote@enron.com, Drew Tingleaf, cahn@enron.com, Jason R Wiesepape, berney.aucoin@enron.com, Michelle Parks, Doug Gilbert-smith, Larry Jester, joe.allen@enron.com, Patrick Keene
- Date
- Mon, 9 Apr 2001 08:28:00 -0700 (PDT)
The Capacity Auction Agreement Working Group for ERCOT (CAAWG - ERCOT) will be the forum to work on the implementation of the standard form agreement and resolution of issues related to using capacity auction products in the ancillary services markets of ERCOT. The CAAWG - ERCOT will hold its meetings at the Commission where a member of the Commission's Market Oversight Division will be present. This group will be filing its final work product in Central Records at 3 pm on Friday, May 4, 2001, for public comment prior to consideration at the Commission's June 14, 2001 Open Meeting. The SPP Stakeholders will be filing a standard form agreement and resolution of issues related to the use of capacity auction products in the SPP ancillary services markets at the Commission at 3 pm on Friday, May 4, 2001 for public comment prior to consideration at the Commission's June 14, 2001 Open Meeting. Because the structure of the SPP ancillary services market is still under development, the focus will be on ERCOT and input and assistance from SPP staff will be sought in the coming weeks. The Working Groups are a direct result of the PUCT Capacity Auction Order. The current time line proposes meeting weekly as Stakeholders to work to resolve the issues, schedules and final products to be included in the auction this fall. Under the current proposal the Capacity Auction Products will be Baseline, Gas Intermediate, Gas Cyclic and Gas Peaking. Each of the PGCs must auction 15% of the Texas Jurisdictional Installed Generation Capacity. The capacity will be sold as a "slice of the system" of each of the divesting PGCs and will not be for any specific unit. During the months of March, April May, October, and November of each year the available entitlements may be reduced proportionately to the average planned plant outage. With respect to the firmness of the products, the PUCT found that the products should be 100% financially firm to provide potential buyers of the entitlements certainty in the products that they are buying. Forced outages are limited to 2.0% of the hours of the entitlement. The Power Generation Companies (PGCs) have recommended using the EEI Master Power Purchase and Sale Agreement and Schedule CA will describe the products available for auction. A copy of Schedule CA will be attached below for your review and comment. Please note that the Schedule CA is not a final document and is an initial proposal from the PGCs. Your review and comments will be essential. Also, if you have any questions or comments as to the process of the CAAWG or the auction process in general please feel free to call me. The working group will meet each Wednesday for the balance of April after which the working group will meet May 1st and May 2nd in anticipation of the proposed May 4th filing date. After the filing, Enron will have the opportunity to file written comments with the PUCT. The Auction process under the rule must be completed prior to September 1, 2001 for the initial auction period. The following is an initial list of issues. 1. What is the timing of schedules for each of the products from the buyer of the entitlement to the seller of the entitlement. 2. Are ancillary services available from the Baseload product? TXU has stated that they cannot provide A/S from their Baseload units. As such, should A/S be removed from all Baseload product offerings from all PGCs so that there is a standard product or should the Baseload offerings include ancillary services when and where available. The argument distills to if the entitlement is more valuable in the market as a standardized product or a differentiated product that may or may not include A/S. 3. What is the delivery point for the entitlement and other operational issues? Should it be a single bus, multiple busses or congestion zones. Congestion zones may change each year, under the current auction schedule, you would bid for the product before you know the final congestion zone. 4. How (or if possible) can responsibility transfers be used for balancing energy? 5. Who will receive OOM payments? 6. What about compensation for other A/S payments? 7. Does released capacity exist, should it exist at all? If so, what happens when the capacity is released. The PGC would like the offering to look like a call option. If the option is not exercised by scheduling, then the capacity is deemed released. This is the interpretation of the PGC,s and not necessarily that of the PUCT or other Stakeholders. 8. How much of a product or entitlement is available in A/S? The order adopting the final rule can be found at http://www.puc.state.tx.us/rules/rulemake/21405/121900adt.pdf the actual rule starts at page 41 of 65. Please review and comment. Thane Thomas Twiggs Enron Corp 1400 Smith Street Houston, Texas 77002 713-853-3199 Voice 713-408-4463 Mobile 713-646-8272 Fax 877-968-8967 Digital Pager or 8779688967@skytel.com