23 Mar 2001, 12:34 UTC
No new plants
- From
- John Neslage john.neslage@enron.com
- Date
- Fri, 23 Mar 2001 04:34:00 -0800 (PST)
This may be of some use, I am still looking C. Discouraging New Power Supplies California is not an easy state in which to build a power plant. Licensing procedures and rules are expensive and time consuming. Environmental regulations are among the most stringent in the nation, and power plants are unpopular neighbors, often sparking resistance from local residents. In California, plants often take three to five years from concept to operation, while in other Western states the process can be as short as one year. The long delays in adding capacity in California had set the state on the road to shortages long before restructuring. Thanks to these barriers, in 1996, as restructuring was debated, California had not seen a new power plant built in a decade. Yet the state still had excess energy generation capacity. Indeed, one reason for restructuring was to let market incentives determine capacity decisions. The architects of restructuring assumed that competition and profit opportunity would bring new power plants to keep electricity supply well ahead of demand in spite of the difficulties state regulations present. And, despite restructuring,s failure to allow a competitive market, restructuring did stimulate new capacity* between March 1998 and the end of 2000 the California Energy Commission had licensed nine new power plants that will generate over 6,000 MW, about 16 percent of the state,s average daily load. But these new plants are so slow in coming*the first won,t be online until mid-2001*they won,t help solve the current shortage. The long delays in adding capacity in California had set the state on the road to shortages long before restructuring. Since 1988, the state energy commission has been predicting that demand would catch up with and surpass supply. But state leaders did nothing to change the barriers that discouraged new companies from building new power plants. At first, discussions of deregulation may have discouraged new investment, since private companies did not know what kind of law the state would pass. But restructuring ended that uncertainty and companies saw an opportunity to make money from growing demand in California. The new plants they are now building will likely assure that the current shortage will not persist. The current policy debate over what to do about the shortage has focused on providing more power plants as soon as possible. Gov. Davis created a "green team" to streamline regulatory review of some projects, but the new process applies to only two of the 13 projects undergoing review. Davis has also proposed a state energy authority to build and operate new power plants, but state ownership and construction will only speed up projects if the state does not follow all permitting and environmental rules, the same result could be accomplished by waiving rules for private power generators and without consuming tax revenues to pay for the plants. But waiving the rules is not likely to be politically acceptable and may not even be wise. A better approach would be to change the regulatory approach without changing standards. California regulators view their roles as ensuring that standards are not violated*they don,t care if the power plant gets built. Thus they make themselves like the troll under the bridge*no one gets by without meeting their terms. State leaders could speed up the process of adding new power plants by changing the regulator,s mission so his goal is to make sure that the power plant gets built without violating any standards* a subtle but important change in approach. Indeed, speeding up the review process by taking a constructive approach to solving problems as they arise, rather than just kicking the problem back to the developer, could improve the environmental quality of the state,s energy supply. New generation plants are cleaner and more efficient than older ones and will displace some of the dirtiest plants in a competitive market. With the right approach, state policy makers can meld the incentives to invest that supply constraints and market prices create with a more positive approach to permitting and environmental reviews to speed up completion of new plants, shortening the span of the state,s electricity shortage and helping prevent future shortages