7 Mar 2001, 11:41 UTC
CPUC FIling -- Enron not mentioned in "cartel"
- From
- Susan J Mara susan.mara@enron.com
- To
- Karen Denne, Mark Palmer, Richard Shapiro, James D Steffes, Jeff Dasovich, Paul Kaufman, Sandra McCubbin, Kathryn Corbally, fergus@brobeck.com, Richard B Sanders, Ronald Carroll, Jeffrey Watkiss
- Date
- Wed, 7 Mar 2001 03:41:00 -0800 (PST)
Sue Mara Enron Corp. Tel: (415) 782-7802 Fax:(415) 782-7854
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
----- Forwarded by Susan J Mara/NA/Enron on 03/07/2001 09:37 AM -----
"Daniel Douglass" <Douglass@ArterHadden.com>
03/07/2001 08:40 AM
To: <Barbara_Klemstine@apsc.com>, <Bob_Anderson@apses.com>,
<Vicki_Sandler@apses.com>, <berry@apx.com>, <dcazalet@apx.com>,
<billr@calpine.com>, <jackp@calpine.com>, <Ken_Czarnecki@calpx.com>,
<gavaughn@duke-energy.com>, <rjhickok@duke-energy.com>, <gtbl@dynegy.com>,
<jmpa@dynegy.com>, <jdasovic@enron.com>, <susan_j_mara@enron.com>,
<Tamara_Johnson@enron.com>, <curt.Hatton@gen.pge.com>, <foothill@lmi.net>,
<camiessn@newwestenergy.com>, <jcgardin@newwestenergy.com>,
<jsmollon@newwestenergy.com>, <rsnichol@newwestenergy.com>,
<nam.nguyen@powersrc.com>, <Curtis_L_Kebler@reliantenergy.com>,
<rllamkin@seiworldwide.com>
cc: <Ken.E.Randolph@dynegy.com>
Subject: Important Filing - Read This
Attached is a document that WPTF members should read right away.? It is a
motion which?was filed by Michael Aguirre, supposedly on behalf of UCAN
(although UCAN is mentioned only in the cover letter and nowhere in the
document itself).? It requests hearings by the Commission to determine the
following:
?
"(1) the cause of the unjust and unreasonable prices being charged for
electricity in California; (2) the utilities efforts to pursue lawsuits
against generators or marketers of electricity and natural gas."
?
The motion?further describes the following scenario which it claims
justifies these hearings:
?
"Five companies operating out of Houston, Atlanta and Tulsa have controlled
the power to set prices of electricity in California.? These companies are:
(1) ?Williams Energy Services and Williams Gas Pipeline Company and their
subsidiaries, which operate out of Tulsa, Oklahoma and control the
electricity generation in Orange County ("Williams");
(2) ?Southern Company Energy and Marketing, Southern Energy California, and
their affiliated companies, which operate out of Atlanta and control
electricity generation in parts of the San Francisco Bay Area consisting of
Contra Costa, Pittsburg, and Potrero ("Southern");
(3) ?Reliant Energy Services, Reliant Energy Power Generation and their
affiliated companies, which operate out of Houston and control electricity
generation in parts of Los Angeles County, Ventura County, and San Bernadino
County, consisting of Cool Water, Etiwanda, Ellwood, Mandalay and Ormond
Beach ("Reliant");
?(4) ?Duke Energy North America and Duke Trading & Marketing and their
affiliated companies, which control electricity generation in parts of the
San Francisco Bay area, the Central Coast, and Ventura and San Diego
counties, consisting of Oakland, Morro Bay, Moss Landing, and South Bay San
Diego ("Duke"); and
(5) ?Dynergy Marketing and Trading and its affiliated companies, which
control electricity in parts of North County San Diego ("Dynergy").? These
companies will collectively be referred to as the "WSRD Cartel."
The members of the WSRD Cartel are each following the same fatally flawed
business plan, and each knows the others are following the same business
plan.? The key defect in WSRD Cartel,s business plan is the impossibility of
raising and lowering the price at which electricity is sold.? In order to
push through deregulation of electricity in 25 states, the WSRD Cartel has
lobbied state officials and the public with claims that they intended to use
deregulated electricity rates to lower the prices consumers and businesses
were paying for electricity.? However, to raise capital from America,s
capital markets, the WSRD Cartel members have represented they would be
using deregulated generation to raise the prices consumers and businesses
were to pay for electricity.? (The "Fatal Flaw" in WSRD,s Business Plan.)
California,s rate payers and utilities are the most recent victims the Fatal
Flaw in WSRD Cartel,s Business Plan.? Members of the WSRD Cartel, along with
its other allies in the power and natural gas business, successfully lobbied
California to deregulate electricity.? In 1996, California adopted
deregulation and thereafter California utiltiies sold off its control of the
gas driven electricity generation to the WSRD Cartel.
The members of the WSRD Cartel have collusively and unlawfully used their
control of the generation units in California,s to unlawfully raise the cost
of electricity to unconscionable levels, to amounts greater than four times
the amount electricity sold for before deregulation. The WSRD Cartel has
used systematic unlawful, fraudulent and unfair business practices to raise
the prices to their current excessive levels.?
The WSRD Cartel has withheld electricity from the market in order to drive
up prices. The WSRD Cartel has used its position of control over natural gas
to unlawfully and fraudulently inflate electricity prices by increasing the
costs natural gas used to generate electricity.? The WSRD Cartel members
have engaged in collusive practices aimed at shifting large volumes of
electricity out of the forward markets and into the real time markets in
order to drive up prices.? The WSRD Cartel members have under bid into the
replacement and other ancillary services markets in order to circumvent the
price caps and to create out of market calls which resulted in exorbitant
and unconscionable prices for electricity."
As mentioned above, UCAN is mentioned in the cover letter but not named in
the filing.? I have written to Michael Shames to confirm whether or not
Aguirre was authorized to file this on UCAN's behalf.
?
Dan
Received: from dymwsm06.mailwatch.com by ArterHadden.com; Tue, 06 Mar 2001
18:09:47 -0500
Received: from dymw0108.mailwatch.com (dymw0108.allegro.net [204.253.83.242])
by dymwsm06.mailwatch.com (8.11.0/8.11.0) with SMTP id f26Mj4Q17556; Tue, 6
Mar 2001 17:45:04 -0500
Received: from 204.253.83.72 by dymw0108.mailwatch.com with SMTP (
WorldSecure Server SMTP Relay(WSS) v4.3); Tue, 06 Mar 01 18:09:57 -0500
X-Server-Uuid: c41a640a-a9e9-11d4-8124-00508bd3f8dc
Received: from imo-r12.mx.aol.com (imo-r12.mx.aol.com [152.163.225.66]) by
dymwsm10.mailwatch.com (8.11.0/8.11.0) with ESMTP id f26NAKi21460; Tue, 6 Mar
2001 18:10:21 -0500
Received: from MEByrnes@aol.com by imo-r12.mx.aol.com (mail_out_v29.5.) id
6.ee.11fc9d7e (3897); Tue, 6 Mar 2001 18:06:24 -0500 (EST)
From: MEByrnes@aol.com
Message-ID: <ee.11fc9d7e.27d6c76d@aol.com>
Date: Tue, 6 Mar 2001 18:06:21 EST
Subject: Request for Hearing - for filing - WordPerfect
To: jbushee@sablaw.com, kmccrea@sablaw.com, rogerberliner@bcjlaw.com,
rcsstl@cdmnet.com, mbrubaker@consultbai.com, anchau@shellus.com,
keith-sappenfield@reliantenergy.com, jsmollon@newwestenergy.com,
jlyoung@sempra.com, napedersen@jonesday.com, athomas@newenergy.com,
fchristi@arterhadden.com, kmcspadd@milbank.com, hchoy@isd.co.la.ca.us,
lgurick@calpx.com, douglass@arterhadden.com, randy_britt@mayco.com,
frank.cooley@sce.com, glwaas@calpx.com, uwuaregion5@earthlink.net,
fmo@sdcity.sannet.gov, jleslie@luce.com, Julesan@aol.com, mshames@ucan.org,
jparrott@sempra.com, kmelville@sempra.com, bill.mccallum@ci.fresno.ca.us,
btenney@landuselaw.com, RonKnecht@aol.com,
furutanj@efawest.navfac.navy.mil, kpoole@adamsbroadwell.com,
mdjoseph@adamsbroadwell.com, rcosta@turn.org, bfinkelstein@turn.org,
theresa_mueller@ci.sf.ca.us, chrisw@greenlining.org, joseh@lif.org,
jnnc@chevron.com, jlondon@gralegal.com, imoosen@gralegal.com,
clpearce@duanemorris.com, phanschen@mofo.com, tmberliner@duanemorris.com,
smoss@hooked.net, epoole@adplaw.com, rschmidt@bartlewells.com,
chilen@llgm.com, edwardoneill@dwt.com, lys@aelaw.com, jsqueri@gmssr.com,
jbennett@gmssr.com, bloomje@la.whitecase.com, pbray@newpower.com,
rick.counihan@greenmountain.com, thoulihan@mdbe.com, mday@gmssr.com,
jmalkin@orrick.com, lindseyhowdowning@dwt.com, mrh2@pge.com, whe1@pge.com,
ssmyers@worldnet.att.net, pxo2@pge.com, pat.williams@dhcmail.com,
wbooth@booth-law.com, jerryl@abag.ca.gov, mgomez1@bart.gov,
askaff@energy-law-group.com, hf@energy-law-group.com, PJPowerLaw@aol.com,
difellman@energy-law-group.com, nryan@environmentaldefense.org,
rrcollins@n-h-i.org, patrickm@crossborderenergy.com,
tomb@crossborderenergy.com, brbarkovich@earthlink.net, pmcdonne@wenet.net,
pjmuller@ricochet.net, berry@apx.com, jbradley@svmg.org,
sberlin@mccarthylaw.com, scottst@mid.org, bill@jbsenergy.com,
cmkehrein@ems-ca.com, jweil@aglet.org, abb@eslawfirm.com,
bpowers@seniors.org, dcarroll@dbsr.com, dkk@eslawfirm.com, ed@clfp.com,
howens@seniors.org, jtachera@energy.state.ca.us, sgreenberg@realenergy.com,
smutny@iepa.com, lmh@eslawfirm.com, hodgesjl@pacbell.net,
rpernell@energy.state.ca.us, kmills@cfbf.com, rliebert@cfbf.com,
aorchar@smud.org, mpa@aelaw.com, jcpaine@stoel.com, mhg@hetrading.com,
dws@keywaycorp.com, nevillm@hdcdojnet.state.ca.us, dwrlegal1@water.ca.gov,
LKristov@energy.state.ca.us, randy.chinn@senate.ca.gov,
firmiyas@dof.ca.gov, rtavares@energy.state.ca.us,
mschwebs@energy.state.ca.us, cohnap@sce.com, costac@sce.com,
lehrerjm@sce.com, shotwejp@sce.com, tlong@turn.org
MIME-Version: 1.0
X-Mailer: AOL 6.0 for Windows US sub 10501
X-WSS-ID: 16BBB1CF52845-01-01
Content-Type: multipart/mixed; boundary=part1_ee.11fc9d7e.27d6c76d_boundary
To: ?All Parties - A.00-11-038, et al.
FROM: ?Michael J. Aguirre, Attorney for UCAN and Ratepayers
UCAN AND RATEPAYERS' REQUEST FOR HEARING - WORDPERFECT FORMAT
Please respond to Julesan@aol.com (Michael Aguirre) with any questions or
comments.
- REQHRNGEMAIL.wpd