13 Nov 2000, 14:21 UTC
Re: issue w/compliance ertificate
- From
- David Redmond david.redmond@enron.com
- To
- Mark Taylor
- Date
- Mon, 13 Nov 2000 06:21:00 -0800 (PST)
Mark, I am not sure I follow this but I will attempt to present my interpretation of your note. I am only restrained from trading those items in clause one if I am responsible for trading them at Enron, and "equities" falls under "securities" in clause one. "Equities" fall under clause one and are therefore not included in clause two. Therefore, since I do not trade equities for Enron, I can trade them on my personal account. Brent Crude futures, I would argue, are "financial instruments," included in clause one. I am not responsible for trading them for Enron. If they fall under clause one they are not included in clause two. Does this mean, since they are not in clause two and I do not trade them for Enron, I can trade them on my personal account? Perhaps you could give me a call, +44 207 783 4928. Thank you, Dave From: Mark Taylor on 10/11/2000 15:56 CST To: Cassandra Schultz/NA/Enron@ENRON cc: David Redmond/LON/ECT@ECT, Paul Simons/LON/ECT@ECT, Peter Crilly/LON/ECT@ECT, Richard Lewis/LON/ECT@ECT Subject: Re: issue w/compliance ertificate This issue was much easier when all we traded were energy commodities, interest rates and currencies. The older versions of the policy provided that no Enron employee may trade any energy commodity for the account of anyone other than Enron. Beyond that, no Enron employee could trade a commodity which was within their area of responsibility. For example, I was not permitted to trade natural gas futures for my own account but, since interest rates and currencies are not within my area of responsibility, I could trade them. As the scope of our trading activities expanded it became more difficult to identify the scope of the company's concern, much less to articulate it. We did however take a stab at it and the result is below. This may be an area which could stand some clarification in the next version of the Policy. For now, I would suggest that the term "security" highlighted below should be read to include equities and therefore not one of the commodities covered in the second numbered clause (i.e. the word "other" refers to items other than those listed in clause (i)). The result is that an Enron employee who does not trade financial instruments, securities, financial assets or liabilities for Enron may trade them for his or her own personal account. To take this a step further, one could argue that an employee who trades the equities of energy companies for Enron should not trade energy company equities for his or her own account but could trade other equities - if it were me, I would certainly make sure that Ted Murphy agreed with my analysis before I did it. Of course, a wide variety of commodities remain clearly off limits for personal trading - metals, ag commodities, bandwidth, freight, lumber, among many others - for all employees. As I remember it, this was done purposely and if anyone disagrees with the scope of the policy they would be wise to discuss the matter with the RAC Group as they make suggestions for Policy revisions to the Enron Corp. board. Employee Trading. No employee of any Enron Business Unit may engage in the trading of any Position for the benefit of any party other than an Enron Business Unit (whether for their own account or for the account of any third party) where such Position relates to (i) any financial instrument, security, financial asset or liability which falls within such employee,s responsibility at an Enron Business Unit or (ii) any other commodity, included in any Commodity Group. Cassandra Schultz@ENRON 11/08/2000 08:32 AM To: Mark Taylor/HOU/ECT@ECT cc: David Redmond/LON/ECT@ECT, Richard Lewis/LON/ECT@ECT, Peter Crilly/LON/ECT@ECT, Paul Simons/LON/ECT@ECT Subject: issue w/compliance ertificate To: Mark Taylor, Legal counsel for Market Risk Management Mark - would you please clarify this issue for us? Thank you, Cassandra Schultz.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
---------------------- Forwarded by Cassandra Schultz/NA/Enron on 11/08/2000 08:26 AM --------------------------- David Redmond@ECT 11/08/2000 03:05 AM To: Cassandra Schultz/NA/Enron@ENRON cc: Araceli Romero/NA/Enron@Enron, Richard Lewis/LON/ECT@ECT, Peter Crilly/LON/ECT@ECT Subject: Re: 3rd Request - RESPONSE NEEDED ASAP - Risk Mgmt. Compliance Certificate Cassandra, Richard asked me to review this document before the traders on the UK Gas Desk would sign it. The UK gas desk adheres to all the risk management requirements of this document. However, in Section VII , Miscellaneous, Employee Trading, the document would appear to prevent any of us trading equities (amongst other commodities) on our personal account as Equity Trading is a Commodity Group. We are unsure if this is the aim of this agreement. We have asked our compliance officer, Paul Simons to clarify the impact of this clause for us. We are not ignoring the document, we are waiting for clarification. Thank you, David Redmond